Critical reception Upon its initial airing, television critics' reviews for "The Crash" were mixed to negative. Its departure from the standard
Mad Men episode structure was described as the strongest yet, and many found it off-putting.
Matt Zoller Seitz wrote, "I’m convinced that metafiction/jazzing around is the only prism through which “The Crash” is anything other than audaciously annoying. More so than any
Mad Men episode I can recall, it doesn't quite feel like a
Mad Men episode, but a bunch of half-formed ideas for a
Mad Men episode". While praising the episode's humor, Seitz criticized the subplot with the African-American burglar in Don's house, viewing it as part of a pattern in the show of minorities being disappointingly uninteresting characters. He also considered the flashbacks to Don's past to be poorly edited and written, and felt that their intended message had already been established by that point in the show's run. Maureen Ryan of
The Huffington Post argued that the episode "was amped up and yet often came off as filler", also disparaging the flashbacks as "embarrassingly thin, predictable slices of melodrama in a show that, at its best, embraces complex, thoughtful ambiguity."
Alan Sepinwall was mixed, writing that much of the episode "was memorable, and a lot of it was funny – even before Ken started tapping and rapping, we got Don shouting about the timbre of his voice and being uncertain about whether he would be “forceful or submissive” (clearly still having last week's games with Sylvia on his mind) – but a lot of it played like parody:
This is “Mad Men.” Now this is “Mad Men” on drugs. Any questions?" He predicted as a result that he would remember the episode chiefly for its unconventionality. Jenny Lower of
Los Angeles magazine argued, "Where
Roger’s acid trip became a plot device for him and Jane to reveal unspoken truths, it’s unclear exactly what this episode accomplished." Sarene Leeds of
Rolling Stone similarly wrote, "If there was anything I learned from "The Crash" – other than Aaron Staton does a mean soft shoe – it was that I'd much rather watch Roger get high." Tim Goodman of
The Hollywood Reporter said, "As a one-off experiment, it’s hard to fault [Matthew Weiner] for trying. A series creator should be allowed that. But I hope Dr. Hecht and his needles don’t show up again any time soon." In
The A.V. Club, however, Emily St. James assigned the website's highest grade (A) to "The Crash" and interpreted it as "an episode of
Mad Men that’s about writing
Mad Men, about locking yourself in a room and driving yourself crazy to come up with that one perfect idea, about wasting a weekend on that process, about trying to top yourself and feeling like you’re losing your mind." She considered no other television episode from the 2013-14 season to be more thought-provoking, and opined, "The whole thing is like a bunch of strands of yarn, lying parallel to each other, and then a cat comes through and starts knocking them around, because it was promised a ball of yarn, and it’s not going to go home without it."
Slate magazine's Seth Stevenson identified vulnerability as its overriding theme, and questioned whether "the amphetamine clockwork of the episode—skies flickering dark then light, days whirring together—[was] meant to evoke the frightening velocity of the era". Paul MacInnes of
The Guardian called it "a grand episode" and praised the writers' ability to make "the viewer [feel] as if they're on drugs too." In 2014, a year after it first aired, Oliver Lyttelton of
IndieWire ranked "The Crash" as one of the series' best entries and wrote, "The episode proved highly divisive when it aired, with some finding it empty and pretentious, but further rewatches have made clear that it’s anything but." Kyle Russell of
Business Insider and Verne Gay of
Newsday also listed the episode as a series highlight, with the latter lauding it as "a glory of comedy, writing, direction and sheer nuttiness." In the
International Business Times, Alex Garofalo ranked "The Crash" as second only to "
The Suitcase" among
Mad Men episodes, hailing it as "an experimental high for the series" and a "manic
fever dream of an episode" in which "each character aggressively numbed his or her personal pain." It was also ranked the show's ninth best episode in a poll of
Entertainment Weekly staff, with Keith Staskiewicz comparing it to the works of
David Lynch.
Ratings The episode was viewed by 2.16 million viewers on the night of its original airing. It drew 0.8 million viewers in the 18–49 demographic. ==References==