Critical reception for
The Dead Fathers Club has been positive, with The Guardian praising the book as "sad fun". NPR and Booklist also praised the book, with NPR citing it as "a lovely and unsettling book".
Entertainment Weekly gave
The Dead Fathers Club a B rating, calling the book "clever" while stating that "the pastiche falls apart toward the end, when our once-likable hero gets mired in the nitty-gritty of revenge." The SF Site and She Knows praised the audio adaptation of the book, with SF Site writing that the book "lends itself well to an audio presentation".
USA Today wrote that the book "has much to recommend it", citing Phillip's narration as a high point of the book.
Kirkus Reviews also praised Phillip's narration. ==References==