The second season was widely received as inferior to the first, but it has been noted that this may be slightly unfair. which Schwartz described as a "real vote of confidence [from] the network", but many attributed placing
The O.C. against the likes of
Survivor,
Joey and
Will & Grace as part of
The O.C.'s decline in popularity. The move improved FOX's performance at the new time slot, but lost the show viewers. The season premiere attracted 8.6 million viewers, but average viewing figures decreased thirty percent from the previous season to 7 million. For the second season the show was nominated for five
Teen Choice Awards winning four of them, including best drama. It was also nominated for the Favorite Television Drama
People's Choice Award.
Kelly Rowan won a
PRISM Award for Performance in a Drama Series Episode, with
Peter Gallagher also getting nominated. Additionally the season finale was nominated for the TV Drama Series Episode award. The introduction of bisexual character Alex, was praised as "an especially charismatic new presence",
Mischa Barton was criticized for her acting skills in portraying Marissa, alongside other noted flaws including "flavorless plots", and "flat new characters who failed to grab the audience's interest".
IGN faulted the move to quickly rekindle the Ryan and Marissa relationship and "abruptly write off Alex and Lindsay, after [making] them a pretty big part of the show" but commended a "compelling story centering on Ryan's brother Trey coming to town, leading to a very dramatic season finale"
Tate Donovan, who played
Jimmy, credited a drop in ratings to "the show moving away from the family dynamic to focus more on the kids". ==DVD release==