Ratings The pilot episode of the season gained 7.5 million viewers and was nominated for a
Writers Guild of America Award for best
episodic drama. As the season progressed, ratings picked up with 8 million viewers tuning into for the third episode and 8.6 million viewers watching the fourth installment. This resulted in
FOX initially ordering an additional six episodes. This was followed by a seven-week hiatus, in which FOX announced it had ordered another five episodes, bringing the total season to twenty-seven. The time-slot for the second half of the season was originally planned for Thursday nights, but facing competition from
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation on
CBS and
Will & Grace on
NBC it was moved to Wednesday nights at 9:00 p.m. instead. Overall season one was the highest-rated new drama of the season among adults aged 18 to 34, averaging a total of 9.7 million viewers. The show picked up four
Teen Choice Awards and was nominated for another two, as well as getting nominated for the Outstanding New Program
TCA Award. In the UK, its two showings a week averaged 1.2 million viewers, and it was one of the highest rating Sunday daytime programs, also attracting fans to E4 on Monday nights. It was also well received in Australia, picking up a
Logie Award for Most Popular Overseas Program in
2005.
Critical response The first season received generally positive reviews from critics, with the
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes reported a 77% approval rating, with an average rating of 6.56/10 and based on 22 reviews. The website's critical consensus reads, "Even though it lacks an original take on teen angst,
The O.C. functions well enough for its target audience, churning plenty of soap storylines out of a talented cast."
Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned a score of 67 out of 100 based on reviews from 17 critics, indicating "generally favorable" reviews. However, the show did come in for some criticism.
San Jose Mercury News criticized the plot and the casting saying that "the storylines usually involve the obligatory three-episode-arc drug problems or lost virginity with dialogue designed to keep a dog up to speed", and that "Whoever at FOX thought Benjamin McKenzie (Ryan on "
The O.C.") could pass for anything younger than 25 should be fired". while
Entertainment Weekly did not think the acting was always up to scratch, stating "it's unfortunate to have all this potential for arm-flinging drama invested in Barton, an actress who can be as flat as a paper doll". It was also denounced for excessive brawling and glamorizing underage drinking. ==DVD release==