Box office As of 25 September 2025,
The Bengal Files has grossed in India, with a further overseas, for a worldwide total of .
Critical response The Bengal Files received predominantly negative reviews from critics. On the
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, four of six critic reviews are negative. Mukund Setlur, writing for
Deccan Herald, called the film a "double-edged disaster" and a "dilemma emerging from incoherent writing and poor editing". Kartik Bhardwaj of
Cinema Express gave the film 1 star out of 5, claiming that it reeked of
propaganda and made for an excruciating experience akin to a bland history lesson, where even the performances could not leave a mark and felt perfunctory. Anuj Kumar from
The Hindu reviewed the film negatively as well, accusing it of using cinema as a tool to divide, and also added that "the makers create their own history around the recorded events". Radhika Sharma of
NDTV found the film unending, disturbingly graphic, gory, and gruesome, while also finding the imagery "in your face" and the performances screechy and over the top. Abhishek Srivastava from
The Times of India gave the film 3.5 stars out of 5, noting that it reveled in shock value, and with scenes of grotesque violence succeeding in evoking anger, despair and reflection, the film also managed to connect at an emotional level, "offering glimpses into suffering that transcended politics". Anurag Singh Bohra from
India Today gave the film 3 stars out of 5, praising the performances and visuals, while also feeling the execution was marred by slow pacing, nonlinear storytelling, and a stretched runtime. Rishabh Suri from
Hindustan Times gave the film 3 stars out of 5, feeling that while the film did get over-indulgent at times in its treatment of history, it was salvaged by "fine performances". Rachit Gupta from
Filmfare gave the film 2.5 stars out of 5, labelling it "a violent and over-dramatised look at partition horrors". Lachmi Deb Roy from
Firstpost gave the film 2 stars out of 5, praising the performances except that of Darshan Kumar, and finding the story gripping while also feeling the characters were not comprehensively written and that the execution could have been better. Titas Chowdhury from
CNN-News18 also gave the film 2 stars out of 5, finding the lengthy runtime to be its biggest weakness, the violence nauseating, and the film as a whole underwhelming even as a piece of art.
Shubhra Gupta from
The Indian Express gave the film 1.5 stars out of 5, finding the performances overwrought, the violence sickening, and the overall execution loose and confused. Shomini Sen from
WION felt that while the story was compelling, the execution was problematic, and the film was too graphic and divisive to be taken seriously. Shilajit Mitra of
The Hollywood Reporter India praised the set extensions and the framing in a couple of countryside scenes, but felt the film made no room for depicting the plight of the Muslims killed in the partition riots and the only solution it offered was answering
communalism with communalism. Anant Gupta of
Scroll.in says, "Other than gore, the film has nothing perceptive to say about
communal violence. It leaps from one scene to another without offering a diagnosis or even a coherent critique of the passions that drive people to commit horrific acts of violence on one another". Gupta further highlights the use of narratives, slogans, and symbols aligned with
Hindutva, a
Hindu nationalist ideology. == Controversies ==