''The Devil's Own'' received mixed reviews from critics. On
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, it has a approval rating based on reviews, with an average score of 5.2/10. On
Metacritic, it has a score of 53 out of 100, based on reviews from 26 critics, indicating “mixed or average reviews.” Audiences polled by
CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of "B−" on an A+ to F scale. On Amazon (Prime Video), audiences view the movie even more highly, with 1,172 reviewers giving it on average of 4.5 stars.
Roger Ebert gave the film 2½ stars out of 4, saying it showed "ignorance of the history of Northern Ireland" and that "the issues involved between the two sides are never mentioned." The review criticized the contrived plot, stating "The moral reasoning in the film is so confusing that only by completely sidestepping it can the plot work at all." Pitt and Ford were praised, with Ebert complimenting the pair, describing them as "enormously appealing and gifted actors, and to the degree that the movie works, it's because of them."
James Berardinelli gave the film 2½ stars out of 4, saying:
Janet Maslin called it an "unexpectedly solid thriller" with a "first-rate, madly photogenic performance" by Pitt; she notes that it is "directed by Alan J. Pakula in a thoughtful urban style that recalls the vintage New York stories of
Sidney Lumet" and "handsomely photographed by
Gordon Willis".
Richard Schickel called it "quite a good movie – a character-driven (as opposed to whammy-driven) suspense drama – dark, fatalistic and, within its melodramatically stretched terms, emotionally plausible"; he said Pakula "develops his story patiently, without letting its tensions unravel."
Entertainment Weekly gave it a "
B+," calling it a "quiet, absorbing, shades-of-gray drama, a kind of thriller meditation on the schism in Northern Ireland." A reviewer for
Salon.com called it "a disjointed, sluggish picture" with a problematic script that "bears the marks of tinkering": "swatches of the story appear to be missing, relationships aren't clearly defined, and characters aren't identified."
Variety said: The film grossed $43 million in North America but it performed better overseas, earning $98 million which brings in the worldwide total of $140 million. Brad Pitt's Belfast
brogue was criticized by several reviewers. In 2024, the website
Irish Central listed it as one of "The Worst Irish Accents in Hollywood Movies".
Cast and crew response In retrospect, Brad Pitt said: "I really like ''Devil's Own''. It was a good schooling for me. Still, I think the movie could have been better. Literally, the script got thrown out." Harrison Ford is also very fond of the movie: "We had a real hard time making it, but Alan [Pakula] made, I think, a really good movie out of it."
British Royal family controversy The film was involved in adverse publicity when, two months before her death,
Diana, Princess of Wales took 15-year-old
Prince William, and 12-year-old
Prince Harry, to see the movie. The movie was restricted to movie-goers aged 15 or older, and the Princess persuaded the cinema to let Prince Harry stay despite him being three years underage. She was criticized for flouting the law, for using her influence to persuade the cinema's employees to flout the law, and because of the movie's subject matter (which was said to glamorize the IRA – highly sensitive given that her sons' great-uncle
Earl Mountbatten was assassinated by the IRA). She later apologized, saying she had been unaware of the film's content. ==Novelization==