Critical reviews In a starred review of
The Everlasting,
Publishers Weekly praised it for its "impressively constructed plot" that "keeps the pages flying on the way to a stunning finale."
Kirkus Reviews called it "an epic time-travel fantasy about how stories from the past can shape our future." Kristen Allen-Vogel called it "a provocative, heartrending fantasy" in a starred review for
Shelf Awareness. Grady Shelton called it "sweet and tender" in a review for
SFF Insiders, and wrote that "like the best of the Arthurian legends and other medievalist stories, it comprises many hallmarks of a new classic poised to stand the test of time." Melody Bowles of the
British Fantasy Society named it her favorite book of 2025.
Gary K. Wolfe praised the novel in his review for
Locus, stating that Harrow offers "some of her most gorgeous and lyrical prose to date".
Awards The novel was nominated for a
Goodreads Choice Award in the Readers' Favorite Fantasy category. The audiobook version, narrated by Sid Sagar and
Moira Quirk, was nominated for an
Audie Award for Fantasy. The novel is a finalist for the 2026
Locus Award for Best Fantasy Novel and the 2026
Hugo Award for Best Novel. == References ==