Critical Vincent Canby of
The New York Times wrote, "Though
The Fifth Musketeer is loaded with intrigue, duels, large scale swordplay, heavy costumes and heavier décor, it is singularly without style or even excitement. In the center of it, Mr.
Bridges the younger seems bewildered in the manner of someone unsure of his real identity."
Dale Pollock of
Variety stated that the film "adds nothing new to the genre, deriving its inspiration totally from the 1939 United Artists release written by
George Bruce, who is credited here along with Dumas", adding that director
Ken Annakin "stifles
The 5th Musketeer with ornate production values, deadly earnest swordplay and dialog as moth-eaten as the peasant costumes. The result? Yawnsville."
Gene Siskel of the
Chicago Tribune gave the film two-and-a-half stars out of four and called it "one of those big, one-star-from-every-country productions. Such films invariably are badly directed... Director Ken Annakin is obliged to give every one of his stars a decent amount of screen time, and the result is a film that moves in fits and starts."
Kevin Thomas of the
Los Angeles Times wrote, "There are some nice moments along the way from a largely nostalgic cast and some reasonably sumptuous settings, with the Schoenbrunn Palace standing in for
Versailles. However, since Ken Annakin's direction and
David Ambrose's script are uninspired,
The Fifth Musketeer tends to be plodding." Rick Groen of
The Globe and Mail asked, "How does a movie this bad ever get made? ... actors recite their lines in a dull monotone and the direction is absolutely wooden; the reaction shots are so studied that one can almost hear the director counting out. Indeed, everyone's timing is way off, as if the whole picture were made in some
Quaalude-induced stupor."
Annakin's assessment In his 2001 autobiography,
So You Wanna Be A Director?, Annakin agreed with the criticisms of the film, feeling he had not done a good job with the actors (in particular
Ursula Andress and Kristel), as well as not translating the script to screen effectively. ==References==