Its wide use of "
sampling" prompted music publishers to file suit against Buchanan and Goodman in July 1956. The two men were also criticized in media of the era, with an anonymous source telling
Billboard, "If we can't stop this nothing is safe in our business." While "The Flying Saucer" was not the first record to quote from famous songs (see "Cool Whalin'" by Babs Gonzales), it was the first popular record to sample directly from the recordings themselves. The comedians made fun of their own predicament by issuing a follow-up song, "Buchanan and Goodman on Trial" (Luniverse 102), which just missed the
Billboard Top Forty, peaking at #42. By November 1956, the novelty song had stood up in court, being labeled as artful and clever. A judge refused to issue an injunction prohibiting the sales of the record. Essentially, the record was considered a new work. This made it legal for artists to sample existing records—a practice that became very popular in subsequent years. Alongside the trial record, Buchanan and Goodman followed the single with more "Flying Saucer" records, resulting in what has been dubbed a "UFO comedy series", Other artists followed suit:
Dewey, George and Jack and the Belltones (three
WHBQ disc jockeys and a local Memphis singing group) recorded their own version of "The Flying Saucer" under the title "Flying Saucers Have Landed" (the DJs did the spoken bits and the Belltones sang the musical snippets). Other versions of "The Flying Saucer" included one by '''
Alan Freed,
Steve Allen,
Al "Jazzbo" Collins and the Modernaires With George Cates' Out Of Spacers
and another by Sid Noel and his Outer Spacemen'''; both records used re-recorded versions of the musical bits. ==Legacy==