John G. A. Pocock's Assessment
Skinner's
Foundations were discussed at a panel at the 95th annual meeting of the
American Historical Association in 1980, chaired by Ralph E. Giesey, with J. H. M. Salmon,
J. G. A. Pocock and Julian Franklin participating, Skinner commenting. The manuscript of Pocock's lecture is now part of the J. G. A. Pocock Collection at the Institute of Intellectual History for the
University of St Andrews. It is an earlier and shorter version of his article
Virtues, Rights, and Manners: A Model for Historians of Political Thought, published in 1981. Pocock praises the
Foundations for presenting "the continuity of Reformation with scholastic thought" and connects the book's themes with his own theses about the influence of
Machiavellian thought not only to American ideology, but on
Scottish Enlightenment as well. Based on Skinner's work, he distinguishes between "two themes or lines in argument in favour of civic liberty". While the humanist (Greek) one argues from a moral viewpoint, i.e. that
liberty is required for
virtus and justice is "the best life for man", the juristic-imperial (Roman) line uses liberty as a concept to describe the result of power (
imperium) going back from a princeps to the people. The former is focused on
positive liberty, the latter on
negative liberty, exemplified by Pocock with the last words of
Charles I that having liberty does not include participation in government. The hypothesis Pocock presents is, in essence, that
liberalism – based on law, especially property rights (which Pocock characterizes "to the jurist" as "the essential object of right") – is unrelated to
virtus, i.e. grounded not in the humanist, but the juristic-imperial strain of arguing for civic liberty. This "possessive individualism", according to Pocock, "defines the individual by his engagement in property transactions"; it is furthermore "long predating
early modern capitalism". Virtue is also a central topic in Pocock's later work about what he calls the
conservative enlightenment. ==References==