Homer gives
Marge a
koi pond for their anniversary, but an endangered "Screamapillar" takes refuge in the pond. Bound by law to care for it, Homer accidentally injures the loud, annoying larva while reading a bedtime story. For trying to bury the larva to cover up the injury, Homer is sentenced to two weeks of
community service for "attempted insecticide and aggravated buggery". Homer begins delivering
Meals on Wheels to an elderly woman, Mrs. Bellamy, who takes a liking to him. She subtly
guilt trips Homer, and later Marge, into becoming her personal servants. When Bellamy turns up dead, having been stabbed with a pair of scissors, Homer and Marge are the prime suspects in the murder, even though they witnessed a man with
braces leaving the murder scene with Bellamy's necklace. The people of Springfield are very suspicious of Homer and Marge, and
Chief Wiggum does not believe their story. Finally, during an inspection of the house,
Maggie is found with Bellamy's necklace, and Wiggum arrests Homer and Marge.
Bart,
Lisa and Maggie are adopted by
Cletus Spuckler, who decides to change their names to "Dingus Squatford Jr." and "Pamela E. Lee". Despite not undergoing
lie detector or DNA tests, both are
sentenced to death by
electric chair. In a bid to spare Marge, Homer confesses to the
warden that he acted alone, and Marge is released. As Homer is sitting in the electric chair, it is suddenly revealed that he is on a new
Fox reality TV show,
Frame Up. Bellamy's murder was merely part of an elaborate
hidden camera scheme, the man with the braces is the show's host, and Bellamy is guest host
Carmen Electra in disguise. Chief Wiggum is annoyed that the police department's time and taxpayers' money was wasted on what turned out to not even be a real case, but is excited to learn he will be in the show and has them give
Lou and
Eddie producer credits. Homer and Marge are reunited with the kids, but Homer is infuriated that he had to suffer just so the show could get higher ratings; as Electra tries to explain, he ends up staring at her breasts. ==Production==