The Moving Picture World said on February 24, 1917, that the film "will be a fit companion piece to the preceding pictures in which the young American star [Minter] has appeared, and affords her a wide opportunity in a difficult role."
Motion Picture News said on March 3, 1917, that the film "is a typical Mary Miles Minter-
Cinderella production. By this we mean that the diminutive star has the same tribulations that she has encountered so many times in the celluloid... These plot high-lights have been incorporated into nearly every picture starring Miss Minter. They will probably continue to form the foundation of Minter releases, because these circumstances are ideal for displaying the star's youth, wistfulness, and engaging mannerisms. The public would probably resent seeing Miss Minter in a different kind of role, just as it wants
Maude Adams to play nothing but
Peter Pan." Proving the
Motion Picture News critic correct, the
Dayton, Ohio Journal review objected to Minter's hairstyle: "Give us back our Mary. In
The Gentle Intruder, Mary is no longer the laughing care-free child. She has her hair done up. Lord! fancy Mary Miles with done up hair. We refuse to stand for it. Of course Mary is gentle and wistful and awfully nice, but we want her with her hair down." ==Cast==