The Good Doctor opened on
Broadway at the
Eugene O'Neill Theatre on November 27, 1973, and closed on May 25, 1974, after 208 performances and eight
previews. Produced by
Emanuel Azenberg and directed by
A.J. Antoon, it starred
René Auberjonois,
Barnard Hughes,
Marsha Mason,
Christopher Plummer, and
Frances Sternhagen. Frances Sternhagen won the
Tony Award for Best Featured Actress in a Play, and the play received three additional Tony Award nominations:
Best Original Score (
Peter Link and
Neil Simon),
Best Featured Actor in a Play (René Auberjonois), and
Best Lighting Design (
Tharon Musser).
Clive Barnes wrote in
The New York Times that "There is much fun here-or at least here and there. It is, however, too anecdotal, with most stories closing with the dramatic ring of a punch-line. Mr. Simon's comic fancy is admirable." A revival was produced by The Melting Pot Theater, at the Theater of the Riverside Church, New York City, from February 1998 through March 1, 1998, with
Andre De Shields,
Jane Connell, and
Gordon Connell. A television movie was made based on the play, with
Edward Asner,
Richard Chamberlain, and Marsha Mason. It premiered on
PBS'
Great Performances on November 8, 1978. Reviewer John O'Connor wrote, "Mr. Simon also includes a special piece for his wife, Marsha Mason, in which the appealing actress gets to play each of
The Three Sisters ... . A press release notes that it is difficult to tell where Chekov stops and Simon begins. That's part of the problem ... . The result falls awkwardly between gentle Chekhovian satire and clever Simon wisecracks. Neither writer is served to advantage." ==Plot overview==