New Jersey (2023) The show received its world premiere in
Millburn,
New Jersey, at the
Paper Mill Playhouse. Previews began on October 12, 2023, with an official opening night on October 22. It played for a limited engagement through November 12. It starred
Jeremy Jordan,
Eva Noblezada, Noah J. Ricketts,
Samantha Pauly,
Sara Chase, John Zdrojeski, Paul Whitty, and
Stanley Wayne Mathis as Jay, Daisy, Nick, Jordan, Myrtle, Tom, George, and Wolfsheim respectively. It was directed by Marc Bruni and choreographed by Dominique Kelly.
Broadway (2024–present) The Paper Mill production transferred to the
Broadway Theatre, with previews from March 29, 2024, and officially opened on April 25, 2024. Jordan, Noblezada, Ricketts, Chase, Pauly, Zdrojeski, and Whitty reprised their roles.
Eric Anderson joined the cast as Wolfsheim. The production is directed by Bruni with set & projection design by Paul Tate dePoo III.
Chilina Kennedy temporarily replaced Chase as Myrtle from July to September 2024. Charlie Pollock took over the role of George Wilson in November 2024. In January 2025,
Ryan McCartan replaced Jordan in the production and
Terrence Mann replaced Anderson temporarily (through April 20, 2025).
Sarah Hyland replaced Noblezada in February of that same year. At the end of March,
Linedy Genao replaced Chase and Austin Colby took over the role of Tom Buchanan.
Michael Maliakel also joined the cast replacing Ricketts as Nick Carraway. In June,
Aisha Jackson replaced Hyland. In March 2026,
Reeve Carney joined the cast as Gatsby alongside his real-life wife Noblezada returning as Daisy,
Corbin Bleu as Nick and
John Behlmann as Tom.
London (2025) The production made its European premiere in
London on 24 April 2025 at the
London Coliseum, having started previews on 11 April, and played a limited run through 7 September 2025. In February 2025, it was announced
Jamie Muscato and
Frances Mayli McCann would star as Jay and Daisy, respectively. The remaining cast includes
Corbin Bleu as Nick,
John Owen-Jones as Wolfsheim,
Rachel Tucker as Myrtle,
Jon Robyns as Tom,
Amber Davies as Jordan, and Joel Montague as George.
South Korea (2025) The musical held its Asian premiere at the GS Arts Center in the
Gangnam District of
Seoul, having played from August 1 to November 9 with
Matt Doyle as Gatsby.
North American tour (2026) In January 2025, the Broadway production announced a North American tour was set to launch with performances set to begin in
Baltimore, Maryland from January 31 to February 7, 2026. In December 2025, Jake David Smith was cast as Jay Gatsby for the tour, with Senzel Ahmady reprising her role as Daisy Buchanan from the South Korean production. Also reprising their roles from the Seoul production are Tally Sessions and
Edward Staudenmayer as George Wilson and Meyer Wolfsheim respectively. Sessions and Staudenmayer's casting were announced with the rest of the main cast in January 2026, just ahead of the tour. ==Cast and characters==