Despite a highly successful opening that attracted more than 1.5 million visitors, The first anchor store to close at the mall was Kitchen and Co., which closed in November 1998 and was replaced with Off Fifth Saks Fifth Avenue Outlet in April 2000. To help increase foot traffic at the mall, the Olathe School District opened an alternative high school inside the mall. Dillard's Clearance Center closed in 2001 and was replaced with
VF Outlet three months later. Old Navy also converted their store into an outlet store that year. Both Oshman's SuperSports USA and Old Navy closed in January 2003. In 2007, DSW shuttered their store once their lease expired. Famous Labels opened in the former Off Fifth Saks Fifth Avenue store and Cosmic Mini Golf relocated to the former Linens 'N Things store. In 2008, the Foozles Bookstore closed and was replaced with Book Warehouse. Also in 2008, Monkey Bizness opened in the former Linens 'N Things store and Cosmic Mini Golf relocated for the last time to the former DSW store. In late 2008, Steve & Barry's filed for bankruptcy and closed in early 2009. VF Outlet also closed by the end of that year. The Great Recession hit the mall hard, as many retailers chose to close their less profitable Great Mall locations, or went under altogether. In an early 2008 Securities and Exchange Commission filing, Glimcher Realty Trust expressed a desire to sell the Great Mall of the Great Plains. In September 2010, Olathe approved a 1.5-cent
sales tax increase at all of the mall's stores to help improve the conditions of the mall. At that time, the mall was at 63% occupancy. That year, Treasure Hunt opened in the former VF Outlet store. Famous Labels closed in early 2011 and Driver License Bureau opened in the center of the mall in June of that year to help bring more customers into the mall. Group USA closed and moved to Oak Park Mall in July 2012. In 2013, the sales tax increase was terminated. Both Hibbett Sports and Treasure Hunt closed in 2014. On February 16, 2015, the mall announced that it would be closing in the fall of 2015. By that time, the mall's occupancy dropped to around 35%. In April 2015, the remaining tenants were given 60 days to close or relocate. Monkey Bizness closed in April 2015 followed by Book Warehouse in May 2015. The Marketplace Food Court was emptied and shut down on June 7, 2015. Cosmic Mini Golf closed on June 13, 2015. By July 2015, only five stores were still open: Burlington Coat Factory, Dickenson Theatres, which was recently renamed B & B Theatres, Sportibles, Zonkers Family Entertainment Center, and the Kansas Driver License Bureau. Sportibles closed by the end of that month and relocated to the Olathe Landing Shopping Center. Zonkers Family Entertainment Center closed on August 2, 2015. B & B Theatres closed on August 17, 2015. On September 1, 2015, the mall's website was taken down. The Driver License Office moved out on December 16, 2015, leaving Burlington Coat Factory as the only store remaining. == Demolition and redevelopment ==