Critical reviews In the
Christian Science Monitor, Katie Ward Beim-Esche wrote, "Believe the hype:
The Hate U Give, Angie Thomas's extraordinary and fearless debut, really is that good." On
Salon, Erin Keane wrote that the novel is "topical, urgent, necessary, and if that weren't enough, it's also a highly entertaining and engaging read." The book also earned
starred reviews from multiple review journals.
Kirkus praised both its writing and timelines: "With smooth but powerful prose ... This story is necessary. This story is important." While praising the overall book in a starred review,
School Library Journals Mahnaz Dar criticized the writing of several characters as "slightly uneven." The ''
Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books'', also gave the book their equivalents of starred reviews.
Awards and honors The Hate U Give debuted at the top of
The New York Times young adult (YA)
best-seller list, It is also an
IndieBound best seller.
The Horn Book Magazine,''
Kirkus Reviews, and
Shelf Awareness, among others, named it one of the best young adult novels of 2017.
Booklist named it one of the best books of the year regardless of genre
. Booklist included the audiobook on their 2017 "Top 10 First Novels on Audio" and 2018 "Top 10 Diverse Novels on Audio" lists. Both the book and audiobook editions are
Junior Library Guild selections.
Challenges The American Library Association listed the book as one of the ten most-challenged books of 2017, 2018, 2020, and 2021 "because it was considered 'pervasively vulgar, contained "drug use, profanity, and offensive language," as well as sexual references, and "was thought to promote an anti-police message." In July 2018, a
South Carolina police union raised objections to the inclusion of the book, as well as the similarly themed
All American Boys by Brendan Kiely and
Jason Reynolds, in the summer reading list for ninth-grade students of
Wando High School. A representative of the police lodge described the inclusion of the books as "almost indoctrination of distrust of police" and asserted that "we've got to put a stop to that." The books remained on the list and Wando's principal was later recognized by the state school library association for her defense of the challenged books. The book was
removed from the school libraries of the
Katy Independent School District due to its explicit language. In 2022, the Edgerton (MN) Public School District school board voted unanimously, 5–0, to remove the book from the freshman curriculum. The board cited profanity and omission of the police officer's viewpoint for its objection to the book. In 2024, the book was banned by Collier County Public Schools (FL), citing, "There's talk of an affair between two adults. Teens engage in heavy petting, talk about having sex and condoms. A teen girl is described as being on birth control, and there's discussion of teen pregnancy and the assumption that a married couple is having sex when they go to their bedroom and turn the television up loud. A woman is revealed to be a sex worker." In 2025,
Budmouth Academy in the United Kingdom removed
The Hate U Give from the reading list for its Year 10 pupils. This was because a parent had complained about sexual scenes in the book, its language and the portrayal of white people as "'the baddies'"; the parent said "'You are teaching my daughters that their inherited skin colour makes then baddies. That is racism'". Other parents and ex-pupils of the school started a petition to put
The Hate U Give back on the reading list. ==Adaptations==