In a contemporary review for
The Village Voice,
Janet Maslin regarded the songs as tawdry affectations of "a boozy vertigo" marred by Waits' vague lyrics and ill-advised puns on an album that is "too self-consciously limited" in mood. "It demands to be listened to after hours", Maslin wrote, "when that cloud of self-pitying gloom has descended and the vino is close at hand". Fellow
Village Voice critic
Robert Christgau was also critical of Waits' compositions, writing that "there might be as many coverable songs here as there were on his first album if mournful melodies didn't merge into neo imagery in the spindrift dirge of the honky-tonk beatnik night. Dig?" In a retrospective review for the
Los Angeles Times,
Buddy Seigal was more impressed by Waits' "touchingly, unashamedly sentimental" songs, calling
The Heart of Saturday Night perhaps the singer's most "mature, ingenuous and fully realized" album. It was ranked number 339 on
Rolling Stone magazine's list of
the 500 greatest albums of all time. ==Track listing==