The House staged its first show,
Death and Harry Houdini at the Live Bait Theatre in the Fall of 2001. Artistic Director Nathan Allen wrote and directed the show which starred company member Dennis Watkins in the title role. The team followed with the critically acclaimed hit,
The Terrible Tragedy of Peter Pan. Allen directed the production, written by company member Phillip C. Klapperich. The show was extended twice, running for five months. The genre-bending Valentine Trilogy spanned three seasons and established the House's dedication to exploring the ideas of Community and Heroes through Storytelling and the use of music. The trilogy began with the critically acclaimed opening chapter of the Valentine Trilogy,
San Valentino and the Melancholy Kid in winter 2004. Playwright and songwriter Allen crafted an epic rock 'n' roll drama about a small band of cowboys who hit the open range with more than cattle herding on their minds. A year later the company transported the story to feudal Japan for the samurai sequel,
Curse of the Crying Heart. In 2006 the company mounted the concluding chapter,
Valentine Victorious, which found reluctant hero Elliot Dodge taking on the corrupt streets of 1930s Chicago while battling his own demons. The House found critical success again in 2006 with
The Sparrow. Chicago Tribune Theatre Critic called it "a fresh, guileless, quirky and entirely lovable celebration of high school memories and small-town goodness, told in the accessible, youthful spirit of the iconic comic book." Following a sold-out run at the
Steppenwolf Merle Reskin Garage Theater, the House remounted the show the following season at the
Apollo Theatre. The House Creative Team collaborated with the American Music Theatre Project and students at
Northwestern University to develop the new musical
Girls vs. Boys. The show premiered at the House in April 2010. In 2014, The House was awarded the
American Theatre Wing's National Theatre Company Grant. In October 2020, Nate Allen announced that he was stepping down from his role as the House's Artistic Director. (He was the only person to hold this position in the company's twenty-year history.) This announcement followed the cancellation of House escape room productions
Nova to Lodestar and
The Last Defender. The COVID-19 pandemic had already force-furloughed most House staff. Allen estimated that the company could survive for another year under pandemic-related limitations, but he explained "what the House deserves is someone to really rebuild a company. I know what that is, but it's not me. That was a commitment I had in my 20s, but I don't have it now." Allen had immeasurable influence on the House and also on several generations of Chicago artists who encountered theatre through the House's signature maximalist style. Lanise Antoine Shelley came on as Artistic Director in 2021 and saw through The House's final season. Of its final season, board president Renee Duba said "Thanks to the hard work and patience of so many—as well as the Shuttered Venue Operating Grant funding we qualified for—we were able to rise from the challenges of the initial pandemic hibernation and point the company in a new direction ... However, our strategic assessment looking to the future made it clear that we did not have the financial momentum or audience/donor support to continue beyond this fiscal year. We chose instead to maximize our current year programming and to honor all present commitments and partnerships with a thoughtfully planned exit from the Chicago theatre scene—and a wealth of pride in what the House Theatre of Chicago has accomplished." ==Production history==