Critical reception On the
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, the film has a 73% score based on 33 reviews. The website's consensus reads, "
The Idiots feels more like an experiment than a coherent narrative, but director Lars von Trier's provocative style and rumination on civilization will leave most audience members feeling like satisfied test subjects".
Metacritic reports a 48 out of 100 rating based on 17 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews". Reactions to the film ranged from strong criticism to strong praise.
A.O. Scott wrote a critical review in
The New York Times, calling the film "a two-hour, semi-pornographic Mentos commercial" and singled out the final scene in particular for strong criticism, stating that the film "descends to truly contemptible emotional brutality". Conversely,
Owen Glieberman in
Entertainment Weekly described the film as "a raw, funny, maddening ramble" where Trier "seeks catharsis by pushing everything to extremes" and described the final scene as "a gripping moment of high torment".
The Idiots was ranked #76 in
Empire magazine's "The 100 Best Films of World Cinema" in 2010. The magazine had previously given it a full five star rating on its release in UK cinemas. It is listed as #941 in the film reference book
1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die.
Sexually explicit scenes More controversy arose over the sexual content, which was unusually explicit for a narrative film.
The Idiots contains a shower scene in which a member of the group (in character as an "idiot") has an
erection and, later, a
group sex scene that includes one couple (faces not seen, stand-ins from the porn industry) having unsimulated
penetrative (vaginal) sexual intercourse. Both instances of explicit content are in view only for a few seconds. The film was cleared for
theatrical release by the
British Board of Film Classification, receiving an
18 certificate. When it was shown on
Film4 (then
FilmFour) in 2000, the erection and the intercourse were obscured by
pixelization, following an order from the
Independent Television Commission.
Accolades The film was shown in competition at the
1998 Cannes Film Festival. •
Bodil Awards (1999) • Won: Best Actress, Bodil Jørgensen • Won: Best Supporting Actor, Nikolaj Lie Kaas • Won: Best Supporting Actress, Anne Louise Hassing • Nominated: Best Film •
Cannes Film Festival (1998) • Nominated: ''
Palme d'Or'' •
European Film Awards (1998) • Nominated: European Film Award, Best Screenwriter •
London Film Festival (1998) • Won:
FIPRESCI Prize, Lars von Trier • Robert Festival (1999) • Won: Best Actress, Bodil Jørgensen •
Valladolid International Film Festival (1998) • Nominated: Golden Spike, Lars von Trier ==References==