According to an opening title card, this is one of several recently discovered "lost episodes" found in the
Griffin family basement; it takes place in March 2007, prior to
O. J. Simpson's
September 2007 arrest for armed robbery.
Lois goes to her book club and asks
Peter to babysit
Stewie. Instead, he invites
Cleveland,
Quagmire, and
Joe and they all play Truth or Dare, which results in a make out session between Cleveland and Joe. After a fiasco involving Stewie attempting to fix their
satellite TV, and getting stuck on the roof, due to Peter's lack of supervision,
Brian tries to tell Peter but he does not listen and instead reads a magazine featuring
Nick Jonas. After Peter starts a pillow fight that turns violent, Lois comes in after Cleveland accidentally punches her in the nose, angry at Peter for not watching Stewie, who has gotten stuck on the roof as Peter
tells the viewers with the “Ladies and Gentlemen
Mr Conway Twitty” gag then later transitions back to Peter attempts to fix the satellite himself, at which point he comes across a raffle ticket from 1989 that he had forgotten to cash in, winning him a chance to play golf with a celebrity of his choice. Ultimately, he chooses O. J. Simpson. Unaware at first of Simpson's
accusation for the murders of his wife Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend Ron Goldman, he grows fearful after Joe convinces him to walk around town with the song "
Dust in the Wind" while thinking about the murders. Ultimately deciding to cash in the ticket, his friends suggest he spy on Simpson during the golf game and try to get him to confess to the murders. Hooking Peter to a wire, his cover is blown when the device shorts out. Simpson laments having lost a chance of escaping the accusation. Feeling guilty, Peter decides that Simpson is actually innocent, and decides to befriend him. Peter brings Simpson home with him to meet the family, who are initially less tolerant of Simpson than Peter (except
Stewie). Brian tries to tell Peter that he should not trust Simpson just because he idolized him as a child but Peter refuses. Deciding to let Simpson stay at their house, word soon gets out of Simpson's presence in Quahog, causing Peter to decide to throw a house party and help everyone else get to know him better. Later that day, Peter and Simpson are met with an angry mob instead led by
Mayor Adam West, intent on driving the latter out of town. Desperate for a place to live without being bothered by furious citizens, Simpson makes a heartfelt speech, professing that he is just as imperfect as everyone else, causing the residents of Quahog to apologize and embrace with him. A split second later, however, the tables turn to a surprise ending as Simpson takes out a knife and kills three people before running off. A furious mob goes on to chase after Simpson, as the Griffins look on, with Peter, wearing a guilty disappointed look, indifferently declaring, "I guess he
did do it." ==Production==