Although the film was well received by critics, it bombed at the box office. De Niro said that the film "maybe wasn't so well received because it gave off an aura of something that people didn't want to look at or know". , 89% of critics have given the film a positive review on review aggregator
Rotten Tomatoes based on 73 critic reviews, with an average rating of 8.30/10. The site's critics consensus states: "Largely misunderstood upon its release,
The King of Comedy today looks eerily prescient, and features a fine performance by Robert De Niro as a strangely sympathetic psychopath."
Metacritic gives it a weighted average score of 73 out of 100 based on 13 critic reviews, indicating "generally favorable" reviews.
Time Out magazine called it the "creepiest movie of the year in every sense, and one of the best".
Roger Ebert of the
Chicago Sun-Times gave the film three stars out of four, writing, "
The King of Comedy is one of the most arid, painful, wounded movies I've ever seen. It's hard to believe Scorsese made it." He also wrote, "Scorsese doesn't want laughs in this movie, and he also doesn't want release. The whole movie is about the inability of the characters to get any kind of a positive response to their bids for recognition." He concluded that the film "is not, you may already have guessed, a fun movie. It is also not a bad movie. It is frustrating to watch, unpleasant to remember, and, in its own way, quite effective." Ebert's cohost
Gene Siskel of the
Chicago Tribune recommended it on his list as part of their "Buried Treasures" in a 1986 episode of their syndicated television series
At the Movies.
Dave Kehr of the
Chicago Reader gave the film a favorable review, calling it "clearly an extension of
Taxi Driver", and that the "uncenteredness of the film is irritating, though it's irritating in an ambitious, risk-taking way".
Joyce Millman of
Salon called it "Martin Scorsese's second-least popular movie, after
The Last Temptation of Christ. Which is a shame, because it's Scorsese's second-greatest film, after
Taxi Driver." However, not all critics gave the film positive reviews. Adam Smith of
Empire magazine called it "neither funny enough to be an effective black comedy nor scary enough to capitalise on its thriller/horror elements".
David Ehrenstein, author of
The Scorsese Picture, noted the mixed response of the film in his 1983 review. He stated that
The King of Comedy "cuts too close to the bone for either large-scale mass audience approval or unanimous mainstream critical acclaim". He believed that the film presented a very critical portrayal of the Reagan administration in contrast to other films made during the administration's early years (although the script was written well before Reagan's election, and shooting began less than five months after Reagan took office). "At a time when the film world piles on simple-minded sentiment in thick gooey gobs, a picture like
The King of Comedy appears a frontal assault. The triumph of the 'little guy' is revealed to be nothing more than lumpen neo-Fascist blood lust."
Pauline Kael of
The New Yorker was one of the critics who disliked the film, describing the character of Rupert Pupkin as "
Jake LaMotta without fists". She wrote that "De Niro in disguise denies his characters a soul. De Niro's 'bravura' acting in
Mean Streets, Taxi Driver and
New York, New York collapsed into 'anti-acting' after he started turning himself into repugnant flesh effigies of soulless characters... Pupkin is a nothing." Scorsese says that "people were confused with
King of Comedy and saw Bob as some sort of mannequin". Scorsese has called De Niro's role as Rupert Pupkin his favorite of all their collaborations. Japanese filmmaker
Akira Kurosawa cited
The King of Comedy as one of his favorite films. German director
Wim Wenders numbered it among his 15 favorite films. In a 2010 retrospective,
Mark Kermode ranked the film among Scorsese's finest.
Sandra Bernhard, who plays Masha in the film, indicated in a 2013 interview that
Jack Black was interested in a remake. However, she dismissed the idea, saying that it was "too late" to do it. Actor
Steve Carell and director
Bennett Miller, both black comedy fans, cited
The King of Comedy as a personal favorite and inspiration to shape the sociopathic character of
John E. du Pont in
Foxcatcher. The screenplay for the 2019 film
Joker, which also features De Niro and is written by director
Todd Phillips and co-writer
Scott Silver, is frequently cited by Phillips as inspiration from both
The King of Comedy and Scorsese's 1976 film
Taxi Driver.
Debate about ending The film provides no definitive answer as to whether the ending is reality or fantasy. In his commentary on
The Criterion Collection DVD of
Black Narcissus, Scorsese stated that
Michael Powell's films influenced
The King of Comedy in its conception of fantasy. Scorsese said that Powell always treated fantasy as no different from reality, and thus made fantasy sequences as realistic as possible. Scorsese suggests that Rupert Pupkin's character fails to differentiate between his fantasies and reality in much the same way. Scorsese sought to achieve the same with the film so that, in his words, the "fantasy is more real than reality".
Taxi Driver connection Rupert Pupkin has been compared to Travis Bickle in
Taxi Driver: both characters have serious issues with
reality testing that is drawing the line between outer objective and inner subjective reality. In her review, entertainment columnist
Marilyn Beck approved
Johnny Carson's refusal to participate in
The King of Comedy, supposedly because he feared that the film could inspire psychopaths like
John Hinckley. Beck considered
The King of Comedy even more dangerous than
Taxi Driver due to its lack of blood and gore, as well as the fact that viewers could easily identify with De Niro. In a documentary featured on the first
DVD release of the film, Scorsese acknowledged the connection between the two characters: "
Taxi Driver. Travis. Rupert. The isolated person. Is Rupert more violent than Travis? Maybe."
Critic's lists •
American Film's list of the Best Films of the 1980s – No. 10 • ''Halliwell's Top 1000'' – No. 180 •
1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die •
Jonathan Rosenbaum: 1000 Essential Films •
The New York Times Guide to the Best 1,000 Movies Ever Made •
Empires
The 500 Greatest Movies of All Time – No. 87 == Awards and nominations ==