Although the novel fell into obscurity after its initial release, it found a new readership when Ballantine Books re-issued it as part of their
Adult Fantasy series in June 1969. The novel has since become widely recognized as one of the most influential and most praised of the genre. Many critics,
Arthur C. Clarke felt that the novel helped cement Dunsany as "one of the greatest writers of this century". The novel's reputation has continued to grow in the ensuing decades. In his review of the 1999 edition for
The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction,
Charles de Lint praised the novel as superlative: "It's not simply the beauty of the language, the astute eye for character, the hint of humor, or even the spell of legendry and wonder, but Dunsany's unique combination of all of the above. Even read today, with all the fantasy novels I've read, his work remains fresh and exuberant".
Gahan Wilson also praised ''Elfland's Daughter'' lavishly, calling it "likely Dunsany's masterpiece" and concluding "that may well be the same as saying it could be the very best fairy story ever written". Other reviewers have been more guarded in their praise.
E. F. Bleiler wrote that the novel included "many stylistic brilliances, but the story suffers from too many shifts of attention".
Jo Walton commented that it "is probably best described as good but odd. [Dunsany] isn't at his best writing characters, which gets peculiar at novel length. What he could do, what he did better than anyone, was to take poetic images and airy tissues of imagination and weight them down at the corners with perfect details to craft a net to catch dreams in. It's not surprising he couldn't make this work for whole novels, when as far as I know, nobody else has ever quite made it work in prose". ==Adaptations==