Garth Brooks in... The Life of Chris Gaines peaked at No. 2 on the U.S.
Billboard 200, and peaked at No. 5 on the
Canadian Albums Chart. In November 1999, it was certified 2× Platinum by the
RIAA, but was considered a disappointment relative to Brooks' other albums. Critical reviews were mixed, often noting widespread confusion or consternation among the public regarding Brooks' use of an alternate persona for the album. Allmusic gave the album 3 stars out of 5, writing: "the tunes might not have much flair, they're all sturdy" and show occasional similarities to
John Mellencamp or
The Beatles. "Judged as Brooks' first pop album, it's pretty good", wrote critic Stephen Thomas Erlewine who believed it might have been an even greater success with more straightforward marketing as Brooks' first pop-rock album. The
AV Club said "at times, it works" and noted Brooks seemed to enjoy "break[ing] out of the rigid confines of country radio" with songs influenced by
The Wallflowers or
funk music, but the overall album suffered because despite some good moments other material was "cheesy and watered-down". Christopher Thalen of
Daily Vault ranked the album at a B-, writing it was "a slightly hesitant first step into a new musical world for Brooks that succeeds more often than it fails - but when it stumbles, it falls hard." A harshly negative review came from
Robert Christgau, whose reviews of Brooks' country music were generally positive but who gave the Chris Gains album a "dud" review consisting only of a small icon of a
bomb with a lit fuse. ==Track listing==