Upon the album's release, Victoria Segal of
Melody Maker was critical of "Camden Town" and "
I'm Only Sleeping", describing them as being "as welcome as haemorragic fever", but felt "the rest [of the album was] actually OK, in a predictably perky,
ska-ed up way". Johnny Cigarettes of
NME was negative in his review, believing the album to be merely a money-making endeavor without "a single good excuse for [it] to exist", although he did note a "couple of mildly agreeable contemplative ballads". He believed that the covers of 'I'm Only Sleeping' and '
Cecilia' were recorded merely for "maximum commercial muscle" and also noted that the single "Camden Town" "borrows a hefty chunk of credible trendiness". He added, "Rope in
Sly and Robbie to try and prove your authentic credentials, roll out the jaunty feel-good 'reggie' ditties, sit back and watch the cash roll in." Evan Cater, writing for
AllMusic, wrote, "
The Lone Ranger has the feel of an amateur demo, populated primarily by drum machines and synthesizers, but despite the weakness of the production, Suggs manages credible covers of
the Beatles' 'I'm Only Sleeping' and Simon and Garfunkel's 'Cecilia'." Cater was not impressed with Suggs' songwriting on the tracks he wrote by himself, but felt that he fared better on the ones he co-wrote with Mike Barson, "who appears to have a stronger sense of melody".
Trouser Press described the album as delivering "much the same ska pop mixture and
music hall jollity as [Madness], but with more weight to the production." In a review of the 2016 reissue,
Record Collector's Mark Elliott commented that the "charming, 60s-influenced, 11-song set hits the sweet spot where an experimental edge packs an impressive commercial punch and everyone emerges with their dignity intact". ==Track listing==