Ratings In its initial American broadcast, "The Long Bright Dark" was seen by an estimated 2.3 million viewers. It was the highest rated series premiere out of any HBO program in the last four years, falling behind only the
series premiere of
Boardwalk Empire, which drew 4.8 million viewers. The episode performed exceptionally well with adults between the ages of 18 and 49, recording a 1.0 rating in that demographic. "The Long Bright Dark" was the fifth highest rated cable telecast of the night by total viewership. The United Kingdom terrestrial premiere was broadcast on February 22, 2014, by
Sky Atlantic, garnering 707,000 viewers.
Critical response "The Long Bright Dark" was critically acclaimed by most critics. Tim Goodman from
The Hollywood Reporter said Fukunaga develops "a beautiful, sprawling sense of place" in the premiere, and identified the ensemble and the writing, which he believed "undulates from effectively brash soliloquies to penetratingly nuanced moments carried by sparse prose", as two of its other most satisfying attributes. Marshall Crook of
The Wall Street Journal agreed, writing the show hits the mark with "good acting, smart writing, and lush cinematography". Willa Paskin of
Slate described the episode as "creepy, gorgeous, unsettling, and searching" and noticed "a literary quality, an accretion of meaningful detail" within the show's narrative.
The Daily Beast Andrew Romano said the premiere, together with the former half of the season, compose "one of the most riveting and provocative series I've ever seen", while
Entertainment Weekly critic Jeff Jensen called it "an enthralling murder mystery about history, culture, and heroic character". Brian Lowry, reviewing for
Variety, called "The Long Bright Dark" a "rich and absorbing" episode where
True Detective immediately assumes a unique identity from other police procedurals, and wrote the cast ensemble consisted of "fine players on the periphery". Writing in
USA Today, Robert Bianco felt McConaughey and Harrelson not only met, but occasionally even exceeded "enormously high" performance expectations of the "golden age of TV acting". David Wiegand of the
San Francisco Chronicle singled out the duo as being "in a class of their own", and
Los Angeles Times journalist Robert Lloyd thought the character work from the two men was of "a very high order". Sarah Rodman of
The Boston Globe, though finding the program's grim tone to be occasionally excessive, opined that the two men successfully engaged audiences enough to invest in the series with their performances. Monaghan also received kudos from Rodman for her work in the episode. Additional praise for ensemble performances, chiefly for McConaughey and Harrelson, came from
Time James Poniewozik,
The New York Times critic Mike Hale, Curt Wagner in
RedEye,
The Independent Sarah Hughes, and Gwilym Mumford of
The Guardian. Bianco said the show avoided character stereotypes,
The Daily Telegraph critic Chris Harvey awarded "The Long Bright Dark" five out of five stars, hailing
True Detective as "the most ambitious TV drama for a long time". Not all critics were as enthusiastic in their reviews of "The Long Bright Dark". Hale, despite commending the flashback narrative, believed the dialogue devolved into "a languid character study and a vehicle for long-winded exchanges about religion and responsibility that are writerly in the worst way." Hank Stuever, writing for
The Washington Post, observed "mumbly, bloodshot fatigue" in the story, and felt the series fell short of its ambitions. "In its better moments,
True Detective feels like a fever dream, but mostly it’s just groggy," Stuever concluded.
Emily Nussbaum of
The New Yorker was especially critical of the show and claimed it relished in "macho nonsense". ==References==