Robert Firsching from
Allmovie gave the film a negative review, writing, "Except for an interesting undersea production design, some extreme and phony gore, and some uncommonly beautiful women,
Las Garras de Lorelei is one of Armando De Ossorio's most unwatchable efforts, and every murder is preceded by an annoying flash of red screen."
The Bloody Pit of Horror awarded the film a mediocre 2/4 stars, noting the film's good use of outdoor locations, haunting music score, and good cinematography. However, they criticized the film's lead actor as being "bland" and "uninteresting", weak creature design, and script.
TV Guide rated the film 2/5 stars, stating, " this odd blend of German legend and '70s Euro-horror conventions is distinguished by the red flashes that precede each gory murder."
The Terror Trap gave the film 2.5 out of 4 stars, calling it "a fairly gory spanish dish, with some nice heart rippings, an attractive cast and a cool creature feature mood". Not all reviews, however, were negative.
Digital Retribution awarded the film a score of 4/5, calling it, "a masterful work of horror which has been shamefully overlooked, both by the audience of its time, as well as today's Saw-hungry crowds". Kurt Dahlke from
DVD Talk gave the film a positive review calling it "[an] unusual love story with torn out hearts", commending the film's moments of suspense, and unusual premise, while also noting the poor creature design. Steve Barton from
Dread Central rated the film a score of 4/5, calling it "[an] over-the-top unintentionally side-splitting comedy". Samm Deighan of
Diabolique Magazine noted the film's script, while "a total mess" but felt that it was refreshing, writing, "If you’re expecting something atmospheric and doom-laden, think again. This blend of horror and fantasy is a lot of fun, with some nice scares and decent effects. The monster’s attacks are surprisingly fast-paced and vicious, and the gore–mostly torn flesh–rises above the film’s meager budget." == References ==