Allmusic reviewer Lindsay Planer stated "The 13 tracks on
Magic Sam Legacy are culled from material initially discarded from his two Delmark studio LPs
West Side Soul (1967) and
Black Magic (1968) ... the John Lee Hooker inspired "I Feel So Good" ... and the spirited instrumental "Lookin' Good," both of which date back to 1966. ... As the recorded legacy of Magic Sam was tragically curtailed when he passed in 1969 at the age of 32, any and all titles featuring Sam as a leader could be considered essential. While recent converts might be best advised to start with either
West Side Soul or
Black Magic,
Magic Sam Legacy is a perfect companion volume, serving artist and enthusiast exceptionally well".
The Penguin Guide to Blues Recordings said "
Legacy may be coming in a bit high for a record that relies heavily on recycled material .... Although it evinces little of the direction he was trying to pursue, this is nevertheless a wormhole addition to his discography". ==Track listing==