Sidney Pollard called the book "without a doubt, a landmark in English historiography".
Robert K. Webb called it "both very important and extremely exasperating".
Geoffrey Best called it a "valuable and exciting book" but noted Thompson's neglect of the "flag-saluting, foreigner-hating, peer-respecting side of the plebeian mind" and asked, "How large a portion of 'the working class' did those 'artisans' form from whom so much of his evidence necessarily comes, and of how many hundreds of thousands of lower-class folk do we remain so much more ignorant that we cannot speak as confidently about them?" In April 2020,
Jacobin magazine launched a podcast series,
Casualties of History, focusing on the book and critical receptions of Thompson’s work, by theorists such as
Asad Haider and Sheila Rowbotham. In December 2023,
BBC Radio 3 issued five episodes of its series
The Essay "reflecting on the legacy, ideas and personal inspiration of The Making of the English Working Class" to mark sixty years since its first publication. ==References==