In its prime, The Mall at Tuttle Crossing boasted over 150 tenants and eateries, which at the time made it the largest enclosed mall in Central Ohio by store count. Although it was quickly overshadowed by the opening of
Easton Town Center and
Polaris Fashion Place, the mall remained strong until 2020 with occupancy rates over 90% and many popular anchor and inline tenants. Starting in 2020, however, the mall began a steady decline in tenancy. Losing some tenants such as
Victoria's Secret and
Pink (Victoria's Secret) during the year. In May 2020, Simon Property Group defaulted on the mortgage with over $114 million in debt from the property, and the mall was foreclosed later in the same year. Occupancy rates were initially remaining strong despite this, boasting an occupancy rate of over 90% at the end of 2021. Which was an increase from the 2020 store count and displayed potential growth for the property. Alongside strong anchors such as
Scene75,
Macy's, and
JCPenney driving significant traffic to the mall. The uptick in tenants was short lived however, as the mall began a significant decline after 2021 in occupancy and reputation. On June 23, 2022, a shooting occurred within the mall, killing one individual as a result of an altercation in a shoe store. The perpetrator, Tyrone Gray was found guilty of murder and inducing panic in 2025 and was sentenced to 21 years in prison. Later in 2022, several stores such as
Red Robin shuttered permanently. In October 2023, Namdar Reality Group purchased the mall for $19.5 million. The malls occupancy rate was under 70% by the end of 2023. And several popular tenants, such as
H&M and
The Childrens Place closed soon after. The mall has lost significantly more stores since, such as the closure of
Forever 21, AVR's Furniture, and
Claire's as tenants within the mall. As of December 2025, the mall boasts minimal original tenants or chains. It is largely occupied by local businesses and kiosks rather than major national chains. == Current anchors ==