Frederick Paul Kiesche III reviewed
The Man of Gold in
Space Gamer No. 71. Kiesche commented that "I say 'bravo' to Professor Barker and impatiently await the next Tékumel novel,
Flamesong. If you love the fantastic fiction of
A. Merritt,
Clark Ashton Smith, or
Jack Vance, you will find a new love in
The Man of Gold. An excellent first novel and another fascinating facet of one man's universe – the Empire of the Petal Throne."
The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction entry written by
David Langford and
Neal Tringham describes the novel as Barker's most successful; "a
bildungsroman full of political intrigue and mysterious artefacts" that unfortunately suffers from "a somewhat disjointed plot." Tringham and Langford opine that Barker was more talented as a
world-builder than he was as a prosaist. A website dedicated to Tékumel collecting comments that the pacing issues reflect Barker's inexperience as a novelist. Another retrospective review, posted on the genre fiction blog
Pornokitsch, describes
The Man of Gold as "a curiously unadventurous adventure", noting Hársan's "naive but reckless" personality and his tendency to drift from one encounter to another without conscious agency. While the story and its characters are bland, the world of Tékumel is awe-inspiring. Rather than "a stand-alone piece of entertainment,"
The Man of Gold should be approached "as a part of an educational process," offering an accessible introduction to Barker's fictional universe and inviting the reader to dream Tékumelani adventures of his or her own. Writing for the
Black Gate website, John O'Neill described
The Man of Gold and its sequels as "a series of well-received fantasy novels." He also lauded Whelan's cover art as marvelous. ==Reviews==