On
Rotten Tomatoes the film has an approval rating of 34% based on 100 critic reviews. The site's critical consensus reads, "
Masterminds great cast and stranger-than-fiction true story are largely wasted on a scattershot comedy with a handful of funny moments and far too much wackiness." On
Metacritic, the film has a weighted average score of 47 out of 100 based on 29 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews". Audiences polled by
CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of "B−" on an A+ to F scale.
Peter Travers of
Rolling Stone magazine gave the film one-and-a-half out of four stars, mainly criticizing its lack of good jokes: "The laughs evaporate almost as soon as they land, and some (make that most) of them don't land at all....
Masterminds owes us our two hours back." On the other hand,
Matt Zoller Seitz of
RogerEbert.com gave the film three out of four stars, stating that "If smart dumb comedies hold a place in your heart, you'll like 'Masterminds.'" Although he acknowledged the film's weakness in its length, structure, and pacing, he emphasized that "Most of the time in these kinds of films the notes of sweetness, naivete and regret feel forced.... Here, though, you believe the sweetness, because Hess and his cast sell it with poker faces."
Richard Brody of
The New Yorker also gave praise to the film, writing that "Yes, the comedy is funny—even when it's not laugh-out-loud funny, it's sparklingly inventive and charmingly loopy—but, above all, it has the religious intensity and spiritual resonance that marks all of Hess's other films, and it extends his world of ideas into wild new realms, extends his vision into darker corners of existence than he had formerly contemplated." He also observed the filmmaking of Hess as "suggest[ing] a kinship with the transcendental cinema of
Robert Bresson and
Carl Theodor Dreyer.... His images belong to a similar realm of astonishment, even if his are frankly comedic where theirs are irreconcilably tragic." The film was a finalist for an
AML Award in film. ==References==