In a contemporary review for
The New York Times, critic
Mordaunt Hall wrote: "The dialogue in this feature is well written and Mr. William's performance is efficient. He knows his character and plays it for what it is worth. ... Mr. William plays with sagacity and a sense of humor, but the story is not as important as it might have been, its fiber being weakened by lurid stuff and bromidic ideas. ... But the overbearing manner of the match king, his steam-roller manoeuvres and his quick wit are exceedingly entertaining." Reviewer John Scott of the
Los Angeles Times wrote: "The new film holds much of interest and much of entertainment value. Its main weakness lies in the story treatment, which does not deal enough with the romantic side of the leading character and his love for the cinema star, and presents too meandering a picture of the match king's industrial coups. But for those who don't go to movies to pick them to pieces. 'The Match King' is recommended." ==Preservation==