The duo released
Prologue on July 19, 2011, their first studio album and the first release under their group name. The San Francisco Chronicle described
Prologue as "bittersweet and beautiful." Following
Prologue’s release, the duo headlined a North American tour. "There By Your Side" from the album was named
National Public Radio's Song of the Day.
Prologue made
Daytrotter,
American Songwriter, and
About.com year-end lists. Their second album,
The Ash & Clay, was released on
ANTI- records on March 26, 2013. Promotion for the album included a tour with
Austin-based artist
Sarah Jarosz, and a November taping of
Austin City Limits. The next album,
Monterey, was released on May 19, 2015 on
ANTI- records. It was well-reviewed, with Rolling Stone calling it a "beautifully realised folk recording," and Paste calling the album, "exquisite." ''All the Things That I Did and All the Things That I Didn't Do
was released on June 29, 2018 on Anti- Records. Rolling Stone'' praised the album, and writer Luke Levenson noted that the bandmates' life changes had been significant influences on its sound, commenting that "both halves of the troubadour twosome have undergone serious life changes, with Joey Ryan fathering his second child, and Kenneth Pattengale overcoming cancer and the breakup of a seven-year relationship." Their fifth album,
The Only Ones, was released on October 18, 2019, and was marketed and distributed by Thirty Tigers. It was relatively short for a studio album, at 25 minutes 33 seconds. This led the band to quip at live performances that they had intended to release an EP, but added two extra songs.
I Only See the Moon was released on May 19, 2023. Banjo, played by Ryan, was added to several songs. A tour of the US was undertaken to support the album. ==Appearances and performances==