The Mountie received mixed reviews from critics. Greg Klymkiw calls
The Mountie Clarkson's "most ambitious project to date", "a solid picture", an "old fashioned western replete with a strange blend of 70s cynicism, grit and ... lush panoramas and a weirdly affecting sentimental streak that would have made John Ford proud." The film is "both unabashedly Canadian and yet presented in homage to a myriad of great western traditions." Liz Braun also gave a positive review, saying there was something "satisfyingly Canadian" about the film.
Susan G. Cole gave the film a "mediocre" rating, describing it as "another meticulously made Canadian feature with a good cast, beautiful music and a gorgeous look," but finding the script extremely lacking: "There isn't a line of believable dialogue or a piece of the action you can't predict, and the ending is ludicrous." Chris Knight, writing for
The National Post, gave the film 2.5 stars, calling it a "taut drama," and thought the Robert Service poems were a "nice touch", at the same time finding "the film stalls during the frequent gun battles, which unfold in an uninspired manner." The film lacks subtlety: "It's as if Grayling had told the townsfolk to boil their dialogue along with their drinking water." Linda Barnard agreed, giving the film 2 stars out of 4, saying the film is "gorgeously shot" but suffers from poor dialogue: "More suited to a made-for-TV movie than theatrical release,
The Mountie winds up with a silly ending before it rides off into the sunset." Ken Eisner praises the cinematography, editing, and music, but complains "the story, dialogue, and acting" are sub-par: "The lines themselves—which fall doggedly in the well-charted territory of "Let's finish this!"—sound more like Xbox shoot-'em-up hiccups than anything in spaghetti westerns, let alone samurai flicks or even
Due South", and even suggests that the film "bears a striking resemblance" to the Old West game,
Red Dead Redemption. Robert Bell found the film culturally retrogressive: "Canada has hopped on the male ego bandwagon, purporting the titular enforcer in red as an ersatz cowboy, literally detailing the generic Western format in the most rudimentary and embarrassing manner possible," opining that the film had no redeeming qualities whatsoever: "Perhaps it's cruel to dote on the sheer ineptitude of this production, from its borderline incoherent action sequences to the misguided cinematography and woefully integrated exposition, but it's truly impossible to imagine anyone taking this film seriously beyond mockery and sheer jaw-dropping amazement." A common thread among reviewers, regardless of how they felt about the film, is the similarity of Walker's performance to that of Clint Eastwood. Linda Barnard in particular did not understand why a Canadian film "spends so much time aping Clint Eastwood it could have been titled
A Fistful of Loonies, in reference to
A Fistful of Dollars. ==References==