Reviews for
The New Order have generally been favorable.
AllMusic's Alex Henderson awards the album four-and-a-half stars out of five, and claims that Testament "delivered its best offering ever" and describes it as "every bit as brutally forceful as
The Legacy." He also called the album the "ideal choice."
The New Order entered the
Billboard 200 album charts about three months after its release. The album peaked at number 136 and remained on the chart for thirteen weeks, making it Testament's longest run so far. "Trial by Fire" and "The Preacher" were released as singles, but neither of them charted. By 1990,
The New Order had sold over 250,000 copies in the U.S.
Accolades • In 2007,
Revolver called it one of their 20 essential eighties thrash albums. • In 2014, Revolver also placed
The New Order on its "14 Thrash Albums You Need to Own" list. • In 2016,
Loudwire ranked the album as Testament's second best. • In 2017, Loudwire also listed the album as the 18th best thrash metal album of all time. • In 2018,
Decibel inducted the album into their hall of fame. • The same year, Loudwire placed it among the best metal albums of 1988. ==Touring and promotion==