Julian Huxley in his
introduction, dated December 1958, compares Teilhard's idea to his own attempts, published in
The Uniqueness of Man (1941) but pursued since before World War I, of unifying humanism and biological evolution as a single process, but separated by a "critical point". In 1961,
Peter Medawar, a British immunologist and Nobel Prize-winner, wrote a scornful review of the book for the journal
Mind, calling it "a bag of tricks" and saying that the author had shown "an active willingness to be deceived": "the greater part of it, I shall show, is nonsense, tricked out with a variety of metaphysical conceits, and its author can be excused of dishonesty only on the grounds that before deceiving others he has taken great pains to deceive himself".
Richard Dawkins in
Unweaving the Rainbow (1998) references Medawar's review as "devastating", and characterises
The Phenomenon of Man as "the quintessence of bad poetic science". Teilhard's publications were viewed with scepticism by the church authorities during his lifetime, and while the
Holy Office did not place any of Teilhard's writings on the
Index of Forbidden Books at any point, it did publish a
monitum or "warning" in 1962, specifically against the then-recent popularity of the posthumously published works by Teilhard: Thus, Teilhard's work in the 1960s saw condemnation both on the part of scientists and of church authorities. In an apparent inversion of this, the work has been reviewed approvingly both from the scientific and the theological point of view in more recent years: For the church,
Pope Benedict XVI made an approving reference to Teilhard's concept of the
Omega Point, in a reflection on the
Epistle to the Romans during a
vespers service in
Aosta Cathedral in 2009. Saying "St. Paul writes that the world itself will one day become a form of living worship", the pope commented on Teilhard: It's the great vision that later Teilhard de Chardin also had: At the end we will have a true cosmic liturgy, where the cosmos becomes a living host. Let's pray to the Lord that he help us be priests in this sense, to help in the transformation of the world in adoration of God, beginning with ourselves. Since then, observers have speculated on a possible rescission of the 1962
monitum on the part of
Pope Francis. Teilhard imagined a stage of evolution characterized by a complex membrane of information enveloping the globe and fueled by human consciousness. It sounds a little off-the-wall, until you think about the Net, that vast electronic web encircling the Earth, running point to point through a nerve-like constellation of wires. Evolutionary biologist
David Sloan Wilson in his 2019
This View of Life: Completing the Darwinian Revolution praises Teilhard's book as "scientifically prophetic in many ways", and considers his own work as "an updated version of
The Phenomenon of Man.": == See also ==