The Political Cesspool has over the years featured many guest appearances, including political activists,
Holocaust deniers, have featured. Author
Jerome Corsi was interviewed in July 2008. During the discussion he spoke about his financial newsletter, and promoted his book
The Obama Nation, which includes several statements that have been widely described as racist; for example, he opined that
US President Barack Obama identifies more with his "African blood" than his American roots and that the President "rejects everyone white, including his mother and his grandparents". Corsi scheduled another promotional appearance on
The Political Cesspool, but one month later he canceled this appearance, citing "travel plans that changed". Edwards said that he believed the incident "just goes to show what incredible pressure everyone in public life is under to never have anything to do with anyone who speaks up for the interests of white people." Fellow authors
John Derbyshire and
Steve Sailer Constitution Party nominee
Michael Peroutka used his appearance in 2004 to promote his presidential campaign. Party member Michael Goza described the show as "Christian/Constitutionalist", and "a great blessing to our cause".
Thomas Naylor, of the Vermont
secessionist organization
Second Vermont Republic, appeared on the show to celebrate
Confederate History Month in April 2007, while American Freedom Party Chairman Bill Johnson appeared to promote his party. Gilchrist's colleague in the Minuteman movement,
Chris Simcox, has also been a guest of the show. Paul Babeu, the sheriff of
Pinal County, Arizona, appeared on
The Political Cesspool on July 10, 2010 to discuss illegal immigration; during the interview, he referred to James Edwards as a "great American". Following Babeu's spokesman's apology, Edwards alleged that Babeu was aware of the show's true ideology prior to appearing on the show, saying: "For Sheriff Babeu to change his mind and now regret coming on our show, for whatever reason, is his right. For him to act as though he had no idea of our ideology is a lie." As a result of the controversy surrounding Babeu's appearance on the show, Arizona
U.S. Senate candidate
J. D. Hayworth asked his primary opponent,
John McCain, to drop several campaign ads featuring McCain and Babeu. In 2011, another sheriff, Dennis Spruell of
Montezuma County, Colorado, also apologized after appearing on the show without knowing its actual agenda. Paleoconservative activist and former presidential candidate Pat Buchanan has appeared twice as of 2011. Self-proclaimed "
racial realist"
Jared Taylor, whom James Edwards considers to be a close friend, Although describing itself as "America First", the show has also hosted foreign guests, including
Croatian white nationalist
Tomislav Sunić, Australian white nationalist
Drew Fraser, Russian
Austrian School economist Yuri N. Maltsev, British lawyer Adrian Davies, Canadian white supremacist
Paul Fromm, Canadian conservative blogger
Kathy Shaidle, and
British National Party (BNP) leaders
Simon Darby and
Nick Griffin; Griffin appeared as a guest before and after his election to the
European Parliament. During his post-election appearance, Griffin attributed the BNP's electoral successes to a fear of "creeping process of
Islamification". Actor
Mel Gibson's father,
Hutton Gibson, has also appeared on the show. During his appearance, he referred to
Pope Benedict XVI as a "homosexual" and claimed that "half the people in the
Vatican are
queer." ==Controversy and criticism==