Regnal numbers follow the usual convention for European monarchs. Antipopes are treated as
pretenders, and their numbers are reused by those considered to be legitimate popes. However, there are anomalies in the numbering of the popes. Several numbers were mistakenly increased in the Middle Ages because the records were misunderstood. Several antipopes were also kept in the sequence, either by mistake or because they were previously considered to be true popes. (As a note, the first pope who chooses a unique name is not identified by an ordinal, only assuming a number after a second Pope takes that same name: like how
Francis thus far is only referred to as "Francis", but when there is a second one, they will be (respectively) "Francis I" and "Francis II".
John Paul I is conspicuous as the only exception: having personally chosen to be called "John Paul the First" from the very beginning of his pontificate; which is merely a footnote given his short reign and the fact that he was followed immediately by John Paul II.) • Alexander:
Antipope Alexander V (1409–1410) was listed in the
Annuario Pontificio as a legitimate pope until the 20th century, when the Pisan popes were reclassified as antipopes. There had already been three more Alexanders by then, so there is now a gap in the numbering sequence. • Benedict:
Antipope Benedict X (1058–1059) was kept in the numbering sequence. • Boniface:
Antipope Boniface VII (974 and 984–985) was kept in the numbering sequence. • By the 16th century, the numbering error had been conflated with legends about a female
Pope Joan, whom some authors called John VIII. She was never listed in the
Annuario Pontificio. •
Antipope John XXIII (1410–1415) was listed in the
Annuario Pontificio as a legitimate pope until the 20th century. • Martin:
Pope Martin I (649–655) is followed by
Martin IV (1281–1285). Due to the similarity between the Latin names
Marinus and
Martinus,
Marinus I and
Marinus II were mistakenly considered to be Martin II and III. • Stephen:
Pope-elect Stephen (752) died before being consecrated. He was previously known as Stephen II, but the Vatican removed him from the official list of popes in 1961. The remaining Stephens are now numbered
Pope Stephen II (752–757) to
Pope Stephen IX (1057–1058). == See also ==