The comic has been ridiculed for its revamping of the Punisher mythos, with Matt Duarte of The Weekly Crisis musing that it "alienated many readers and made the character toxic until
Garth Ennis engineered his revival some years later". Nick Nadel of
ComicsAlliance wrote, "Even horror legend
Bernie Wrightson's artwork couldn't make Angel Punisher and his weird spiky guns not look completely silly and dated".
Cracked.com's Maxwell Yezpitelok opined that the storyline "completely undermined the intent of the character who had the simplest goal of any superhero ever" and that it felt like "the sort of bullshit premise that could have only come from the mind of a coke-fueled TV executive pitching a toy-friendly Punisher
animated series where they don't actually show him killing people". Ethan Kaye of
Topless Robot succinctly stated in regards to the volume, "Thank God we have Garth Ennis to give us back the Punisher who liked guns and bombs again". 4thletter's Gavin Jasper said, "
Purgatory still doesn't get as much hate as it deserves. Angel Punisher isn't a completely unusable idea. As a fan of
Franken-Castle, I'd be a hypocrite for suggesting such a thing. If Ennis felt like it, I'm sure he could come up with a way to make it work.
Remender and
Ostrander (the last guy to write
Punisher before this status quo) could make it work. Here, though, there's nothing that redeems such a bonehead concept."
Chuck Dixon, writer of various
Punisher comics throughout the early 1990s, criticized the alterations made to the character's backstory, asserting, "I don't think origins like
Batman's or Punisher's should be visited over and over again with everyone adding their two cents until the sum of all added details don't fit any more" and "Punisher's origin has been similarly screwed up, changing in the identities of his family's killers, making it a purposeful rather than random act". == References ==