Historian Isabelle Dervaux has described the reception this painting received when it was first exhibited at the official Paris Salon of 1874: "Visitors and critics found its subject baffling, its composition incoherent, and its execution sketchy.
Caricaturists ridiculed Manet's picture, in which only a few recognized the symbol of modernity that it has become today". Shortly after it was completed, the painting was sold to baritone
Jean-Baptiste Faure. It was sold in 1881 for 5,400 francs to the art dealer
Paul Durand-Ruel, who gave it several names:
Enfant regardant le chemin de fer, ''Le pont de l'Europe
, A la Gare St. Lazare
, and later just Gare St. Lazare
. It was sold on 31 December 1898 for 100,000 francs to American Henry Osborne Havemeyer. His wife Louisine Havemeyer left 2,000 artworks to the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York on her death in 1929, but she divided a small collection, including The Railway'', among her three children. The painting was donated to the
National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C. in 1956 on the death of her son Horace Havemeyer. In
The Painting of Modern Life,
T.J. Clark writes: "The steam and smoke from the railyard ... hang in the air for a few seconds before evaporating. For the little girl watching, time stands still. The woman who looks up at the viewer keeps her place in her book with one finger, expecting the moment to pass: our attention is banal and short-lived (we are male passersby, dragging her out of her identity as governess and chaperone for an instant, but only as long as it takes her to stare us out of countenance), and soon enough we sense that really the woman is somewhere else, still in her novel’s dream of consciousness. Pictures are interceptions: in a second, the air will clear and the reader find her place again in the book. (Or her places, to be more accurate: she seems to be reading back and forth in the story, with finger and thumb keeping two different points of re-entry open.) And yet the book itself, the pages, the streaks of print, the dog-eared cover; the puppy, the bracelet, the snapped-shut fan; the little girl’s hair-ribbon, the gleam on the governess’s straw hat: they are thinglike and permanent—permanent in their mere being for the eye—as only oil paint can make them. Even the steam spreads out with an equal and opposite dull force to the railings that press it back." ==See also==