Record Mirror Ronnie Gurr wrote "
The Scream, a masterpiece that, for six months, I failed to recognise as such, was a harrowing listening experience." Since its release,
The Scream has received a number of accolades from the music press.
NME rated it at No. 58 in their "Writers All Time 100 Albums" list in 1985. Don Watson of the
NME in 1986 described the album's music as "something that whipped the past into a great whirlpool of noise, pulling the future down".
Uncut magazine placed it at No. 43 in their list of the 100 greatest debut albums. It was featured in the books
1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die, and
Colin Larkin's
All Time Top 1000 Albums. In 2006, music critic Garry Mulholland included it in his book
Fear of Music about the 261 greatest albums since punk and disco. In 2007,
Record Collector wrote that "it stands as one of the great debut albums from any era". In 2016,
Les Inrockuptibles rated it as one of "The 100 Best British Albums" in a special issue. In 2017,
Q included it in their list of "the debut albums that changed music" with "revolutionnary sounds". Journalist
David Cavanagh wrote in 2016: "
The Scream - released on Polydor after Peel had repeatedly cajoled record labels to sign the band - was to influence the sound of early U2, the Cure, the Cocteau Twins and My Bloody Valentine. Each one of these bands has influenced at least four hundred others".
The Scream placed the group among the pioneers of
post-punk, as
Robert Smith of
the Cure contended: When
The Scream came out, I remember it was much slower than everybody thought. It was like the forerunner of the
Joy Division sound. It was just big-sounding.
The Scream has been influential on a large number of genres and artists. Joy Division's
Peter Hook, who saw the group in concert in Manchester in 1977, said about
The Scream: "Siouxsie and the Banshees were one of our big influences ... The Banshees first LP was one of my favourite ever records, the way the guitarist and the drummer played was a really unusual way of playing." Joy Division's drummer Stephen Morris said: "[their] first drummer Kenny Morris played mostly toms" and "the sound of cymbals was forbidden", "the Banshees had that... foreboding sound, sketching out the future from the dark of the past".
Steve Albini of
Big Black praised guitarist John McKay for the noise he created, stating that "
The Scream is notable for a few things: only now people are trying to copy it, and even now nobody understands how that guitar player (you know, the one who's been replaced by everyone in England) got all that pointless noise to stick together as songs", and further adding, "good noise guitar is like an orgasm." Elsewhere, Albini recounted that he "admired and emulated... Wire, Siouxsie and the Banshees, This Heat."
Thurston Moore of
Sonic Youth said that all of the records he owned in the mid-1970s "got kind of put into the basement. And they were supplanted by" the debut albums of bands like "Talking Heads and Siouxsie and the Banshees. It was a completely new world, a new identity of music that was an option for youth culture". Moore, who also included "Hong Kong Garden" in his 38 favorite songs of all time, stated about this album and the group: "Siouxsie and the Banshees, did they release a better record than
The Scream?" While playing his favourite records on
BBC Radio 6,
Jim Reid of
the Jesus and Mary Chain commented: "'Jigsaw Feeling' from
The Scream album... it was brilliant, amazing. That's a reason why I made music". When he included
The Scream in a list he did for
The Quietus of the 13 records that "chiselled out The Jesus And Mary Chain",
Morrissey said that
The Scream was Siouxsie and the Banshees' best album, he selected "Mirage" to be played during intermission before all the concerts of his
Kill Uncle and
Your Arsenal tours. Morrissey's main composer,
Boz Boorer, rated
The Scream highly, ranking it second in his "Top Five Desert Island Album Selection", right after
Electric Warrior by
T. Rex. Boorer stated: "Another big influence on my playing is John McKay... That first Siouxsie record was quite incredible sounding, and it started me in thinking that music didn't have to be any certain way—that there could be many different influences in music and it didn't have to be a single, strict avenue. That first Banshees album has a lot of jarring guitar that rubs against what you'd think was going to or maybe should happen over a part, and that changed my thinking quite a bit".
Massive Attack covered and
sampled "Metal Postcard (Mittageisen)" on their song "Superpredators (Metal Postcard)" in 1997 for
the soundtrack to the movie The Jackal: they also released "Metal Banshee", which was a different version sampling "Metal Postcard".
Faith No More covered "Switch" in concert and cited this first Siouxsie and the Banshees' album as one of their influences.
Bobby Gillespie of
Primal Scream said that he was inspired by their debut album: "They had a sound unlike any other band" and the songs were "a realisation that life is difficult, not normal pop song material.
The Scream was the first record through which I experienced these themes, where the band's music mirrored the lyrics perfectly", with "a
film noir atmosphere". He praised guitarist McKay for delivering "quicksilver notes of beautiful sonic violence". Gillespie also wrote: the band "were a new kind of rock", and McKay "reinvented rock guitar playing".
Garbage lead singer
Shirley Manson cited it as one of her all-time favourite records.
Brett Anderson of
Suede included
The Scream on a list of albums titled "current fascinations".
Marc Almond of
Soft Cell also explained why the songs mattered to him: "
The Scream made a real impression on me. I loved the way they turned these suburban things into nightmares—that was a great influence on early Soft Cell stuff".
Tracey Thorn of
Everything but the Girl remembered 1978 as an important music year. "Back then when I only had five or six records I'd listen to each of them over and over, knowing every beat, every word, every scratch. Elvis Costello's
My Aim is True,
The Scream by Siouxsie and the Banshees, The Jam's
In the City,
Moving Targets by Penetration, and
Another Music in a Different Kitchen by Buzzcocks". == Track listing ==