Reviews of the album in the UK music press were mixed.
NME critic Tony Stewart praised the album, writing, "Although the predominant musical influence is black (
ska, bluebeat,
reggae and
soul), it's wrapped in ferocious
rock'n'roll: the kind of hybrid that so many other British bands have tried to contrive but, in comparison, failed to make convincing ... This album embraces two decades of black and white music, gives it perspective and then goes on to reflect the modern rock'n'roll culture ... It's the kind of album that's musically fathomless and it will probably establish the Specials as true hopes for the '80s. At the very least, this debut is essential for anybody who wants to know what's going on in rock'n'roll today".
Record Mirrors Simon Ludgate described the Specials as "
Madness' older, more responsible brother" with "a social conscience" and "greater vocal flexibility", further lauding the album's production for its faithfulness to the Specials' live sound. Dave McCullough of
Sounds agreed that the album had not fulfilled its potential, stating, "There are no rough edges to upset you, nothing new to shock you ... The Specials seem to have lost the attacking, forward-looking, forward moving, almost militant momentum that was witnessed and promised from the beginning".
Legacy In a retrospective review for
AllMusic, Jo-Ann Greene described the record as "a perfect moment in time captured on vinyl forever ... It was an utter revelation—except for anyone who had seen the band on-stage, for the album was at its core a
studio recording of their
live set, and at times even masquerades as a gig". She felt the album captured the feeling of "Britain in late 1979, an unhappy island about to explode", and that "The Specials managed to distill all the anger, disenchantment, and bitterness of the day straight into their music". However,
Mojos David Hutcheon, reviewing the reissue, felt that "
Specials doesn't feel quite as exciting as it did 23 years ago". In June 2000,
Q placed
The Specials at number 38 on its list of the 100 greatest British albums ever.
Pitchfork featured
The Specials at number 42 on its list of the 100 best albums of the 1970s.
Rolling Stone included the album at number 68 on its list of the 100 best albums of the 1980s, as the album was not released in the US until 1980. In 2013,
NME ranked
The Specials at number 260 on its list of "
The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time". The album was included in the book
1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die. ==Track listing==