Columbia Pictures used their original serial ''The Spider's Web
as the basic template for many of its early serials: the daring hero and his assistants adopt disguises to battle an exotic, secretive villain and his lawless gang. In The Spider Returns,'' The Gargoyle wears robes which would not look out of place being worn by
Flash Gordon's longtime nemesis
Ming the Merciless. Both serials feature a dramatic wardrobe enhancement to the Spider's original magazine appearance: his simple black cape and head mask are over-printed with a white spider's web pattern and then matched with his usual plain black
fedora. This striking addition gave the
silver screen Spider an appearance more like that of a traditional
superhero, like other pulp and comics heroes being adapted for the era's movie serials; it also made the serial Spider look less like the very popular
Street and Smith pulp hero
The Shadow, which also had been produced by Columbia and starred
Victor Jory.
James W. Horne, who had co-directed the 1938 Spider serial with
Ray Taylor, was in complete charge of the 1941 sequel. By this time, Horne was filling his serials with tongue-in-cheek melodramatics, ludicrous fight scenes (in which the hero fights six or more men, and wins), and ridiculous-looking machines. For this reason, action fans have often dismissed
The Spider Returns as an inferior serial, but others consider it one of Horne's best, and a worthy sequel. While The Spider does take on half-a-dozen henchmen at a time, he doesn't always come off the clear winner. Horne keeps the action fairly straight until the last chapter, when he inserts some obvious humor (two henchmen, exhausted from their fistfight, haphazardly swing at each other and then collapse). The action-filled screenplay employs a typical serial formula of fistfights, gun battles, explosions, and car chases, not forgetting secret weapons, death traps, and hairbreadth escapes as The Gargoyle tries to steal some top secret plans. The Spider serials are unique in that The Spider is also sought by the police with the same vigor that he is sought by criminals. The one real difference between this and the first serial is the police know Wentworth goes undercover at times in disguise as petty criminal Blinky McQuade; they work with him following the leads he uncovers as McQuade.
Dave O'Brien, who had performed The Spider's acrobatic stunts in ''The Spider's Web'', is now a full-fledged second lead playing the role of Wentworth's assistant Jackson. This appearance led to a starring role in Columbia's later serial,
Captain Midnight. Only three of the main participants in ''The Spider's Web'' (Warren Hull, Kenne Duncan, and Dave O'Brien) are on hand for this sequel. ==Reception==