Based on five reviews,
Metacritic assigned the
Breaking Dawn – Part 1 soundtrack an
average score of 63, indicating "generally favorable reviews". Heather Phares, reviewing for
Allmusic, said "Regardless of the strengths and failings of the
Twilight Saga movies, their soundtracks captured the mood of each book perfectly", and said
Breaking Dawns soundtrack "follows suit, delivering more than a few love songs that are surprisingly angst-free compared to the previous soundtracks." Phares concluded, "Still, the most notable thing about [the soundtrack] is its unabashed romanticism, and the album more than serves its purpose as a
Twilight-branded wedding playlist."
Entertainment Weekly critic Kyle Anderson stated of the soundtrack's second single, "'Jar of Hearts' songstress Christina Perri's fantastically opulent 'A Thousand Years' sets the tone for
The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn—Part 1: stark acoustic strums, cascading strings, and a piercing croon expressing undying adoration." Despite awarding the album a B grade, Anderson noted, "If anything, this is the narrowest
Twilight soundtrack yet: Even when the volume shifts from quiet to slightly less quiet, these weepy tunes about eternity and erotic mythical beasts grow wearisome." In a mixed (two-out-of-four stars) review, Randall Roberts of the
Los Angeles Times said of the featured songs, "As with all of the installments, half are good, half aren't — all depending on your mood and tolerance for soft rock." However, Roberts admitted, "Those uninterested in slow, weepy ballads should avoid like the plague the Imperial Mammoth, Sleeping at Last and Christina Perri songs, each of which will cause the vulnerable to melt." For music site
Consequence of Sound, Caitlin Meyer said that the
Twilight soundtracks had "become a holiday in themselves", but said "Sadly,
Breaking Dawn, Pt. 1 fails to follow suit, as it ultimately underwhelms, indulging too much in the melodramatic." Meyer finally noted, "At the end of the day, a whole collection of lethargic, clichéd songs is hardly a compelling listen[,] meaning that
Breaking Dawn decisively should be
Breaking Yawn and hopefully
Part 2 is a little more inspiring." ==Charts==