Some Catholics criticized "The Vatican Rag" as blasphemous. After one show at the
Hungry I, Lehrer's performance of the song led to a confrontation with the actor
Ricardo Montalbán, who happened to be in the audience. According to a former Hungry I bouncer, Montalbán approached Lehrer in a fit of rage, yelling, "I love my religion! I will die for my religion!" to which Lehrer responded: "Hey, no problem, as long as you don't fight for your religion." In May 1967, a
Putnam County, New York, schoolteacher used Lehrer's "Vatican Rag" and "
National Brotherhood Week" as examples of modern satire for her seventh-grade class; the outcry was such that the school board banned the songs and censured the teacher, and she quit three months later and left the area. Conversely, fans of Lehrer consider the song one of his best compositions.
Vulture included the song on its 2016 list of "The 100 Jokes That Shaped Modern Comedy". In 2000, "The Vatican Rag" was the last song played by the jazz radio station
WNOP before it converted to a Catholic talk format. ==References==