Critical response All seasons of
The Wire have received positive reviews from major television critics, with seasons two through five in particular receiving near universal acclaim, with several naming it the best contemporary show and one of the best drama series of all time. The first season received mainly positive reviews from critics, On the
review aggregator Metacritic, the first season scored 79 out of 100 based on 22 reviews. Another review postulated that the series might suffer because of its reliance on profanity and slowly drawn-out plot, but was largely positive about the show's characters and intrigue. Critics felt the show was testing the attention span of its audience and that it was mistimed in the wake of the launch of the successful
crime drama The Shield on
FX. After the first two episodes of season two,
Jim Shelley in
The Guardian called
The Wire the best show on TV, praising the second season for its ability to detach from its former foundations in the first season. Jon Garelick with the
Boston Phoenix was of the opinion that the subculture of the docks (second season) was not as absorbing as that of the housing projects (first season), but he went on to praise the writers for creating a realistic world and populating it with an array of interesting characters. The critical response to the third season remained positive.
Entertainment Weekly named
The Wire the best show of 2004, describing it as "the smartest, deepest and most resonant drama on TV." They credited the complexity of the show for its poor ratings. The
Baltimore City Paper was so concerned that the show might be canceled that it published a list of ten reasons to keep it on the air, including strong characterization, Omar Little, and an unabashedly honest representation of real world problems. It also worried that the loss of the show would have a negative impact on Baltimore's economy. At the close of the third season,
The Wire was still struggling to maintain its ratings and the show faced possible cancellation. Creator David Simon blamed the show's low ratings in part on its competition against
Desperate Housewives and worried that expectations for HBO dramas had changed following the success of
The Sopranos. As the fourth season was about to begin, almost two years after the previous season's end, Tim Goodman of the
San Francisco Chronicle wrote that
The Wire "has tackled the drug war in this country as it simultaneously explores race, poverty and 'the death of the American working class,' the failure of political systems to help the people they serve, and the tyranny of lost hope. Few series in the history of television have explored the plight of inner-city African Americans and none—not one—has done it as well." Brian Lowry of
Variety wrote at the time, "When television history is written, little else will rival 'The Wire.'"
The New York Times called the fourth season of
The Wire "its best season yet." Doug Elfman of the
Chicago Sun-Times was more reserved in his praise, calling it the "most ambitious" show on television, but faulting it for its complexity and the slow development of the plotline. The
Los Angeles Times took the rare step of devoting an editorial to the show, stating that "even in what is generally acknowledged to be something of a golden era for thoughtful and entertaining dramas—both on cable channels and on network TV—
The Wire stands out."
Time magazine especially praised the fourth season, stating that "no other TV show has ever loved a city so well, damned it so passionately, or sung it so searingly." Several reviewers called it the best show on television, including
Time,
Entertainment Weekly,
Slate, the
Philadelphia Daily News and the British newspaper
The Guardian, also collected in a book,
The Wire Re-up.
Charlie Brooker, a columnist for
The Guardian, has been particularly enthusiastic in his praise of the show, both in his "Screen Burn" column and in his
BBC Four television series
Screenwipe, calling it possibly the greatest show of the last 20 years. In 2007,
Time listed it among the one hundred best television series of all-time. In 2013, the
Writers Guild of America ranked
The Wire as the ninth best written TV series. In 2013,
TV Guide ranked
The Wire as the fifth greatest drama and the sixth greatest show of all time. In 2013,
Entertainment Weekly listed the show at No. 6 in their list of the "26 Best Cult TV Shows Ever," describing it as "one of the most highly praised series in HBO history" and praising Michael K. Williams's acting as Omar Little.
Entertainment Weekly also named it the number one TV show of all-time in a special issue in 2013. In 2016,
Rolling Stone ranked it second on its list of the 100 Greatest TV Shows of All Time and ranked it fourth in 2022. In September 2019,
The Guardian, which ranked the show #2 on its list of the 100 best TV shows of the 21st century, described it as "polemical, panoramic, funny, tragic or all of those things at once", saying it was "beautifully written and performed" and was both "TV as high art and TV wrenched from the soul" and "an exemplar of a certain brand of intelligent, ambitious and uncompromising television". In 2021,
Empire ranked
The Wire at number four on their list of the 100 Greatest TV Shows of All Time. Also in 2021,
The Wire was ranked first by the
BBC on its list of the 100 greatest TV series of the 21st century. In 2023,
Variety ranked
The Wire as the seventh-greatest TV show of all time. Critics have often described the show in literary terms: the
New York Times calls it "literary television;"
TV Guide calls it "TV as great modern literature;" the
San Francisco Chronicle says the series "must be considered alongside the best literature and filmmaking in the modern era;" and the
Chicago Tribune says the show delivers "rewards not unlike those won by readers who conquer
Joyce,
Faulkner or
Henry James." 'The Wire Files', an online collection of articles published in
darkmatter Journal, critically analyzes
The Wire racialized politics and aesthetics of representation.
Entertainment Weekly put it on its end-of-the-decade, "best-of" list, saying, "The deft writing—which used the cop-genre format to give shape to creator David Simon's scathing social critiques—was matched by one of the deepest benches of acting talent in TV history." Former President of the United States
Barack Obama has said that
The Wire is his favorite television series. The 2010
Nobel Prize in Literature Laureate,
Mario Vargas Llosa, wrote a very positive critical review of the series in the Spanish newspaper
El País. The comedian turned mayor of
Reykjavík,
Iceland,
Jón Gnarr, has gone so far as to say that he would not enter a coalition government with anyone who has not watched the series.
Robert Kirkman, creator of
The Walking Dead, is a strong follower of
The Wire; he has tried to cast as many actors from it into the
television series of the same name as possible, so far having cast
Chad Coleman,
Lawrence Gilliard Jr.,
Seth Gilliam, and
Merritt Wever.
Awards for
The Wire at the 63rd Annual Peabody Awards
The Wire was nominated for and won a wide variety of awards, including nominations for the
Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Writing for a Drama Series for "
Middle Ground" (2004) and "
–30–" (2008),
NAACP Image Award for Outstanding Drama Series for each of its five seasons,
Television Critics Association Awards (TCA), and
Writers Guild of America Awards (WGA). Most of the awards the series won were for season 4 and season 5. These included the
Directors Guild of America Award and
TCA Heritage Award for season 5, and the
Writers Guild of America Award for Television: Dramatic Series for season 4, plus the
Crime Thriller Award,
Eddie Award,
Edgar Award, and
Irish Film & Television Academy Award. The series also won the
ASCAP Award,
Artios Award, and
Peabody Award for season 2. The series won the
Broadcasting & Cable Critics' Poll Award for Best Drama (season 4) and won
Time critics choice for top television show for season 1 and season 3. Despite the above mentioned awards and unanimous critical approval,
The Wire never won a single
Primetime Emmy Award, receiving only two writing nominations in 2005 and 2008. Several critics recognized its lack of recognition by the
Academy of Television Arts & Sciences. According to a report by
Variety, anonymous Emmy voters cited reasons such as the series' dense and multilayered plot, the grim subject matter, and the series' lack of connection with
California, as it is set and filmed in Baltimore.
Academia In the years following the end of the series' run, several colleges and universities such as
Johns Hopkins,
Brown University, and
Harvard College have offered classes on
The Wire in disciplines ranging from law to
sociology to
film studies.
Phillips Academy, a boarding high school in Massachusetts, offers a similar course as well. In an article published in
The Washington Post, Anmol Chaddha and
William Julius Wilson explain why Harvard chose
The Wire as curriculum material for their course on urban inequality: "Though scholars know that deindustrialization, crime and prison, and the education system are deeply intertwined, they must often give focused attention to just one subject in relative isolation, at the expense of others. With the freedom of artistic expression,
The Wire can be more creative. It can weave together the range of forces that shape the lives of the urban poor."
University of York's Head of Sociology, Roger Burrows, said in
The Independent that the show "makes a fantastic contribution to their understanding of contemporary urbanism", and is "a contrast to dry, dull, hugely expensive studies that people carry out on the same issues". The series is also studied as part of a Master seminar series at the
Paris West University Nanterre La Défense. In February 2012, Slovenian philosopher
Slavoj Žižek gave a lecture at
Birkbeck, University of London titled
The Wire or the clash of civilizations in one country. In April 2012, Norwegian academic Erlend Lavik posted online a 36-minute video essay called "Style in
The Wire" which analyzes the various visual techniques used by the show's directors over the course of its five seasons.
The Wire has also been the subject of a number of academic articles by, amongst others,
Fredric Jameson (who praised the series' ability to weave
utopian thinking into its
realist representation of society); and Leigh Claire La Berge, who argues that although the less realistic character of season five was received negatively by critics, it gives the series a platform not only for representing reality, but for representing how realism is itself a construct of social forces like the media; both commentators see in
The Wire an impulse for progressive political change rare in mass media productions. While most academics have used
The Wire as a cultural object or case study, Benjamin Leclair-Paquet has instead argued that the "creative methods behind HBO's
The Wire evoke original ways to experiment with speculative work that reveal the merit of the imaginary as a pragmatic research device." This author posits that the methods behind
The Wire are particularly relevant for contentious urban and architectural projects. == Broadcast ==