The original story forming the basis of the film by Slavin and George was first optioned then rejected by
Eagle-Lion. It was announced in early September 1948 as RKO's first production following
Howard Hughes takeover of the studio. Hughes reputedly offered the script to directors as a test for presumed communist leanings. Director
Joseph Losey would claim
the film was a “touchstone for establishing who was not a "red": you offered [it]... to anybody you thought was a communist, and if they turned it down, they were.” According to Losey, 13 directors turned down the film including himself, though this number has since been disputed.[5]
John Cromwell said it was the worst film script he had ever read,[6] while
Nicholas Ray departed shortly before production began. Rewrites were frequent and extensive, and the script had to pass through many hands before a final draft was constructed, including those of
Art Cohn,
James Edward Grant,
Charles Grayson and
Herman Mankiewicz. The script was still considered incomplete even with these contributions, leading RKO to bring on veteran screenwriter
Robert Hardy Andrews to polish what would become the final iteration of the screenplay. The completed script contained significantly less political messaging, and leaned much closer to a traditional melodrama. To add to these difficulties, there was considerable turnover among the cast as well.
Merle Oberon was reportedly on salary as the film's female lead for several months before RKO announced that she would be replaced by
Jane Greer, who was again quickly moved to a different production. In January of 1949,
Paul Lukas was reportedly brought on to play the communist leader. He collected nearly $50,000 before RKO moved on from him in March.[8] Production began in April 1949 under
Robert Stevenson and lasted a month.[9] Hughes and RKO took great lengths to ensure the credibility of the film's anti-communist messaging, going so far as to contact Luis J Russel, an ex-FBI agent and
HUAC investigator, for genuine Communist Party cards to use as models for the prop cards employed in a communist meeting scene. Some of RKO’s early plans for the film even included a prologue by communist informant
Elizabeth Bentley, who would introduce the film with a “carefully written” speech. Newsreel footage of
J. Edgar Hoover was requested, but denied because the FBI feared "persons of communist sympathies" would seek to undermine the project's intentions.[5] Robert Ryan, a liberal, was the only available contracted RKO actor and only agreed to be cast out of fear for his career.[10] The initial local release disappointed expectations as showings in Los Angeles and San Francisco grossed about 40-50 percent below the average. In response, Hughes announced a delay in “the national release” of the film on October 14, 1949. While Hughes still insisted the title
I Married a Communist was the most marketable aspect of the picture, his staff maintained the title must be changed, and a lengthy search was begun. Hughes' reluctance made the decision difficult. After scores of rejections, the title was officially announced as
The Woman on Pier 13 in January 1950.[4] The film's final certified cost came to $831,360. ==Reception==