William Ruhlmann of
AllMusic said that the album "consisted of familiar ballads, dating back to the 1940s for Johnny Mercer's "Dream" (another choral performance not unlike the Pied Pipers' hit version) and coming up to the present for Williams versions of hits like Tony Bennett's "This Is All I Ask" and Jack Jones' "Wives and Lovers." "Softly, As I Leave You" was a good piece of material"
Variety reported that the album showed "Andy Williams still leads the way through soloing neatly on "This Is All I Ask" and "A Fool Never Learns".
American Record Guide referred to it as a "most pleasurable album"
Record Mirror calls the Williams' family collaboration "smooth adult music with style, and loads of entertainment value." Nigel Hunter of
Disc notes "Andy is featured on solocut on items like 'This is All I Ask', and 'September Song', wIth his wife on 'Let It Be Me'." It was given a three-star rating by
The Encyclopedia of Popular Music as well. along with
AllMusic,
Disc, and
Record Mirror. ==Track listing==