Dave Langford reviewed ''Terry Carr's Best Science Fiction of the Year 15
for White Dwarf'' #84, and stated that "as always well chosen, a dozen of 1985's finest stories". Wendy Graham reviewed
Best SF of the Year 15 for
Adventurer magazine and stated that "One of the dullest in this normally excellent annual collection. Half of the stories are alright, half unspeakably naff."
Awards The anthology placed third in the 1987
Locus Poll Award for Best Anthology. "Sailing to Byzantium" won the 1985
Nebula Award for Best Novella, was nominated for the 1986
Hugo Award for Best Novella and the 1986
SF Chronicle Award for Best Novella, and placed second in the 1986
Locus Poll Award for Best Novella. "Flying Saucer Rock & Roll" was nominated for the 1985
Nebula Award for Best Short Story and the 1986
Hugo Award for Best Short Story, and placed eighth in the 1986
Locus Poll Award for Best Short Story. "A Spanish Lesson" placed eleventh in the 1986
Locus Poll Award for Best Novelette. "Snow" was nominated for the 1985
Nebula Award for Best Short Story and the 1986
Hugo Award for Best Short Story, and placed third in the 1986
Locus Poll Award for Best Short Story. "Shanidar" placed twenty-first in the 1986
Locus Poll Award for Best Novelette. "All My Darling Daughters" placed seventh in the 1986
Locus Poll Award for Best Novelette. "Of Space-Time and the River" placed sixth in the 1987
Locus Poll Award for Best Novelette. "A Gift from the Graylanders" was nominated for the 1985
Nebula Award for Best Novelette and the 1986
Hugo Award for Best Novelette, and placed eighth in the 1986
Locus Poll Award for Best Novelette. "The People on the Precipice" was nominated for the 1985
British Science Fiction Award for Best Short Fiction. "The Only Neat Thing to Do" was nominated for the 1985
Nebula Award for Best Novella and the 1986
Hugo Award for Best Novella, won the 1986
SF Chronicle Award for Best Novella, and placed first in the 1986
Locus Poll Award for Best Novella. ==References==