There was some hype leading up to the release of the album.
Entertainment Weekly writer David Browne said he "eagerly await[ed]" it in March 1993, a month before it was set to be released. Nevertheless, the album received mixed to negative reviews.
The Star-Telegram compared the album to the
South Park album
Chef Aid, arguing that "the subversion [included in
The Simpsons and
South Park] is only skin-deep, especially when both shows thrive on the type of money-grubbing merchandising that results in junk like
Chef Aid: The South Park Album and
The Simpsons The Yellow Album, both released just in time for Christmas." The
Tampa Bay Times said the album "is an uninspired collection whose best feature is a too-tiny takeoff on the cover of ''Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band''," noting that songs such as "Ten Commandments of Bart" sounded dated, though others like "
Sisters Are Doin' It for Themselves" are praiseworthy. ==Track listing==